3 4 CHAIRMAN: Good morning, Mr. Murphy. 5 - The Tribunal of ...

8714:33:201 you got the figure that appears on these pages. And just to take, for example,2 my recollection and I'm subject to correction, I don't have a transcript. But3 my recollection is that you said that the figure that you put on page No. 272964 was the figure you got from the Forex machine?14:33:385 A. Uh-huh.6 Q. 528 Correct.7 A. Yes.8 Q. 529 So was that inclusive or exclusive of the commission or the handling fee?9 A. That would be inclusive.14:33:4810 Q. 530 Well that brings me back to the point then. In other words, the figures that11 appear on the transaction dockets for the 9th of March, it should be straight12 forward because there is the same handling. It should be straight forward if13 you multiply the figure exchange for 1,000 pounds Sterling by four you should14 get the figure for 4,000 pounds Sterling, isn't that's correct? Because the14:34:1015 figure comes straight off the machine. You don't subsequently deduct the 216 pounds?17 A. No, I don't.18 Q. 531 So consequently what Mr. Holland has put forward doesn't make any sense. Isn't19 that correct?14:34:2320 A. Well I am getting confused with these figures being thrown at me and I haven't21 looked at them so ...22 Q. 532 To counteract what I put forward this morning, Mr. Holland has suggested that23 we should deduct two pounds and that would make the figures balance.2414:34:3825 CHAIRMAN: No no. I think Mr. Holland's point was that if you apply the rates26 of exchange on that day, that in order to get to the figures that we have in27 evidence you must include two pounds.2829 JUDGE FAHERTY: Yes.14:34:5430Premier Captioning & Realtime Limitedwww.pcr.ie Day 839