3 4 CHAIRMAN: Good morning, Mr. Murphy. 5 - The Tribunal of ...

11815:23:341 JUDGE KEYS: There is four minutes between the timing on the documentation2 between the Sterling transaction and then the further lodgement to the, to both3 children's accounts. So they happened within minutes of each other.415:23:525 JUDGE FAHERTY: Ms. Carruth, if I could put it this way. And if you look at6 the sequence of events that would appear from the documentation we have. That7 occurred on the 9th of March. And this might assist your recollection.8 Perhaps it won't but I put it forward.915:24:0610 As we understand it, somebody presented to the Irish Permanent on the 9th of11 March at 10:24 with Sterling of 4,000 and a transaction was conducted where a12 sum of 4,119.59 was received.13 A. Yes.1415:24:2715 JUDGE FAHERTY: At 10:28 somebody, obviously be it yourself or somebody else,16 stepped in at that juncture to teller No. 2 and lodged, I am not saying it was17 you, because I don't know whether it was, perhaps you will tell us, 4,119.59 to18 the account of Mr. Ahern. Are you with me so far?19 A. Yes.15:24:462021 JUDGE FAHERTY: You then appear, if you don't, if you weren't involved as you22 say in Sterling from the documentation you would appear at that juncture then23 to have stepped out from teller No. 2 and allowed some other at 10:28 to24 present himself or herself with 1,000 Sterling for conversion. They then step15:25:1225 out, it would appear from the documentation, and you step in again with one26 whatever, 1,028.40 to lodge to Cecelia Ahern and ditto with Georgina Ahern.27 That is the sequence of events of the documents that we see, and I am only28 going on the documents, Ms. Carruth, you understand?29 A. Yes.15:25:3630Premier Captioning & Realtime Limitedwww.pcr.ie Day 839