26.03.2013 Views

Download Here - Islamic Books, Islamic Movies, Islamic Audio, All ...

Download Here - Islamic Books, Islamic Movies, Islamic Audio, All ...

Download Here - Islamic Books, Islamic Movies, Islamic Audio, All ...

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

Page 150 of 215<br />

Ghaemiyeh center of computerized researches www.Ghaemiyeh.com<br />

ABU TALIB The faithful of Quraysh<br />

and the Prophet of Islam. If he didnt do so, he wouldnt be able to perform the great<br />

.deeds he had performed or to defend the Prophet and his mission<br />

( . . . A Look at the Verse (Surely you cannot guide whom you love<br />

explaination<br />

As for the verse: (Surely you cannot guide whom you love, but <strong>All</strong>ah guides whom He<br />

pleases Quran, 28:56), we showed the reasons behind distorting the meaning of this verse<br />

and saying that it concerned Abu Talib and we uncovered the secrets behind fabricating<br />

the tradition. Although the fabricated tradition, which distorted the meaning of the<br />

Quranic verse, was refuted, we thought that we had to talk about distorting this verse in<br />

.some points<br />

There were some people, who fabricated traditions about this verse, other than Saeed<br />

bin al-Mussayyab and Abu Hurayra that we just refuted them and their series of<br />

narrators. We wanted here to discuss two other traditions concerning the same verse<br />

and to discuss their narrators. a. Abu Sahl as-Sariy bin Sahl from Abdul Quddooss ad-<br />

Damashqi from Abu Salih that ibn Abbas said: The verse (Surely you cannot guide<br />

whom you love, but <strong>All</strong>ah guides whom He pleases) was revealed about Abu Talib; the<br />

Prophet (s) insisted upon him to be a Muslim but he refused, so <strong>All</strong>ah revealed this<br />

verse.[492] Ath-Thahabi said about as-Sariy: Ibn Adiy considered him as weak and<br />

said that he pirated traditions and ibn Kharash considered him as a liar. Then he<br />

mentioned some of his traditions and said before them: and among his disasters<br />

(wonders or oddities)and among his afflictions![493] Al-Ameeny considered him as<br />

one of the liars according to many historians.[494] As for Abdul Quddooss ad-Damashqi,<br />

Abdur Razaq said: I havent seen Ibnul Mubarak ascribing the word liar openly<br />

except to Abdul Qudooss. Al-Fallass said: They (the historians) agreed upon leaving<br />

his traditions aside. An-Nassaiy said: He was not trusty. Ibn Adiy said: His<br />

traditions were denied whether in their series of narrators or their text.[495] Ismaeel<br />

bin Ayyash said: I dont witness against one of being a liar except against Abdul<br />

Quddooss.[496] Abdullah bin al-Mubarak said: Being a highwayman is better to me<br />

than to narrate a tradition from Abdul Quddooss ash-Shami.[497] As for Abu Salih We<br />

1

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!