Download Here - Islamic Books, Islamic Movies, Islamic Audio, All ...
Download Here - Islamic Books, Islamic Movies, Islamic Audio, All ...
Download Here - Islamic Books, Islamic Movies, Islamic Audio, All ...
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
Page 154 of 215<br />
Ghaemiyeh center of computerized researches www.Ghaemiyeh.com<br />
ABU TALIB The faithful of Quraysh<br />
After all this, we didnt find an improvised saying weaker than the saying of az-Zajjaj<br />
when pretending that: The Muslims agreed upon that this verse had been revealed to<br />
concern Abu Talib.[507] When was this consensus of the Muslims? Yes! It was in the<br />
world of imagination and illusion! Was there any evidence confirming this false pretense?<br />
Didnt he fear the bad end of this disgraceful accusation or the responsibility of such a<br />
reckless decision? The least thing in his saying was excluding Ahlul Bayt and their<br />
followers, the Shia, who refuted this false pretense, from among the Muslims and<br />
excluding another group of the Prophets companions, who acknowledged the truth and<br />
confessed the faithfulness of Abu Talib, because if he didnt exclude these people from<br />
the Muslims, his pretense about the consensus would by invalidated by a saying of any<br />
one of Ahlul Bayt or the companions. The strange thing in this concern-and how much<br />
wonders and strange things there were in this subject-was that his evidence about this<br />
illusory consensus was a false tradition mentioned without any series of narrators so that<br />
we could find whether the narrators were liars, fabricators or something else. But it was<br />
undoubtedly that the tradition was derived from those false traditions that were just<br />
refuted and he might add to them something of his imagination to make the little lie grow.<br />
The contradiction was apparent in the tradition and the marks of fabrication were clear<br />
between the words ascribed to Abu Talib: O my nephew! I know that you are truthful<br />
but I hate to be said that Abu Talib slackened when about to die until he said: but I<br />
will die on the religion of the sheikhs Abdul Muttalib, Hashem and Abd Manaf.[508] We<br />
didnt want to repeat the argument about this fabricated tradition but we liked to refer<br />
to the saying of al-Qurtubi, who found the word consensus so big and he wanted to<br />
lessen something of its sharpness so he commented: It is more correct to say: The<br />
most of the interpreters agreed upon that the verse was revealed concerning Abu<br />
Talib.[509] But he wasnt saved from what az-Zajjaj had fallen into because the two<br />
pretenses had no evidence nor they depended upon reason or reality. The same was the<br />
saying of ibn Katheer when saying about this verse: It was proved in the two Sahihs[510]<br />
that the verse was revealed about the Prophets uncle Abu Talib, who protected the<br />
Prophet (s), defended him, assisted him and loved him greatly; natural love and not<br />
(legal!)[511] Then he cited those fabricated traditions, which were already refuted,<br />
and then he sent his decision indifferently without thinking of any responsibility or<br />
5