17.11.2014 Views

dfgiVej

dfgiVej

dfgiVej

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

“I am the Last Brick and I am the Last of the prophets” 143<br />

their books. They misunderstood the sayings of their prophets<br />

because they took them too literally.<br />

Second, if Farhan Khan’s understanding is accepted, the<br />

matter will remain unsolved. This is because the analogy only<br />

speaks of one missing brick when, according to Farhan Khan,<br />

there are supposed to be two missing bricks in the palace.<br />

Farhan Khan believes in the physical ascent of Hazrat ‘Īsā as to<br />

heaven and if the hadīth is taken literally, the brick representing<br />

Hazrat ‘Īsā as should also be missing. A question that arises from<br />

this acceptance of Farhan Khan’s meaning is: When Hazrat ‘Īsā as<br />

comes back, where will that brick go? As it can now be seen<br />

clearly, this is a flawed understanding and Ahmadī Muslims are<br />

not willing to accept it.<br />

Third, Farhan Khan brings a quotation of Hazrat Imām<br />

Ibn Hajar al-‘Asqalānī rh and writes, “[Hazrat] Mirzā Tāhir<br />

Ahmad[ rh ] quoted Ibn Hajar Al-Asqalani out of context in<br />

regards to the rest of his statement.” 138 Farhan Khan then goes<br />

on to emphasize that the hadīth is about the prophets and the<br />

discussion about their laws is a separate one. However, the fact<br />

of the matter is that the conclusion drawn by Imām Ibn Hajar rh<br />

at the end of his paragraph is identical to the conclusion drawn<br />

by the Ahmadī Muslims. There is no denying that! Ahmadī<br />

Muslims firmly believe that this analogy is about the prophets<br />

but not in the literal sense. The purpose of the analogy is to<br />

speak about the laws brought by those prophets. This is the<br />

same as the conclusion drawn by Imām Ibn Hajar rh and it has<br />

even been recorded by Farhan Khan on Page 13 of his book:<br />

138<br />

Ibid.

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!