Table 4.13 Anticipated cost <strong>of</strong> abatement treating odour emissi<strong>on</strong>s <strong>from</strong> high or very high grease/smoke situati<strong>on</strong> Design Flow Rate (m/s 3 ) Up to 1.5 Up to 2 2.5 3.5 4.5 Abatement System Capital Cost 72 M<strong>on</strong>thly M & R Cost Annual M & R Cost Total Yearly cost ESP <strong>and</strong> CF £7500 £155 £800 £2,660 ESP <strong>and</strong> counteractant £8,000 £180 £0 £2,160 ESP <strong>and</strong> UV/oz<strong>on</strong>e £10,00 £165 £ 450 £2,430 ESP <strong>and</strong> CF £14,000 £200 £1400 £3,800 ESP <strong>and</strong> counteractant £12,500 £225 £0 £2,700 ESP <strong>and</strong> UV/oz<strong>on</strong>e £15,500 £210 £900 £3,420 ESP <strong>and</strong> CF £13,000 £200 £900 £3,300 ESP <strong>and</strong> counteractant £12,500 £225 £0 £2,700 ESP <strong>and</strong> UV/oz<strong>on</strong>e £16,500 £225 £1,350 £4,050 ESP <strong>and</strong> CF £20,000 £250 £2,100 £5,100 ESP <strong>and</strong> counteractant £19,000 £275 £0 £3,300 ESP <strong>and</strong> UV/oz<strong>on</strong>e £26,000 £275 £1,800 £5,100 ESP <strong>and</strong> CF £21,000 £250 £2,700 £5,700 ESP <strong>and</strong> counteractant £19,000 £275 £0 £3,300 ESP <strong>and</strong> UV/oz<strong>on</strong>e £31,000 £285 £2,700 £6,120 4.10.2 Relative cost effectiveness <strong>of</strong> odour abatement systems Table 4.14 compares <strong>the</strong> anticipated level <strong>of</strong> odour c<strong>on</strong>trol against <strong>the</strong> estimated cost for installing <strong>and</strong> operating a system. Of those systems that c<strong>on</strong>tain odour c<strong>on</strong>trol potential <strong>the</strong> abatement systems fall into two categories: • Equipment <strong>of</strong>fering good odour removal at a low capital cost but medium to high running costs; or • Equipment <strong>of</strong>fering good odour removal at a high capital cost with low running costs. Table 4.14 Anticipated relative cost effectiveness based <strong>on</strong> a well maintained system Abatement Type Level <strong>of</strong> <strong>Odour</strong> Abatement Capital M<strong>on</strong>thly M&R Annual M&R Panel <strong>and</strong> Bag N<strong>on</strong>e Low Medium Low Panel, Bag <strong>and</strong> HEPA N<strong>on</strong>e Low to medium Medium High Pre, Fine <strong>and</strong> CF High Low Medium High
Panel, Bag, HEPA <strong>and</strong> CF High to very high ESP <strong>and</strong> CF High to very high ESP <strong>and</strong> counteractant Medium to high * 73 High Medium High High Low Low High Medium N<strong>on</strong>e ESP <strong>and</strong> UV/oz<strong>on</strong>e High Very high Low Low * level <strong>of</strong> abatement difficult to quantify using c<strong>on</strong>venti<strong>on</strong>al odour measurement techniques.