11.11.2012 Views

Metalogos The Gospels of Thomas & Philip & Truth

Metalogos The Gospels of Thomas & Philip & Truth

Metalogos The Gospels of Thomas & Philip & Truth

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

point, traditionally obscured in scriptural translation<br />

and largely ignored by commentators, clearly has<br />

the most far-reaching theological implications.<br />

It is simply ungrammatical, whenever there are<br />

alternate forms either available or readily<br />

constructed in a given language, for a word to be<br />

used to refer to a being <strong>of</strong> the opposite gender—<br />

thus for example Hebrew/English )ybn/prophet<br />

and h)ybn/prophetess. 1 But furthermore, xwr itself<br />

is very occasionally used as <strong>of</strong> masculine gender,<br />

as in Ex 10:13: hbr)h-t) )#n Myrqh xwrw, ‘the<br />

east wind brought the locusts’, where the verb )#n<br />

is in the qal perfect third-person masculine<br />

singular. Thus xwr could elsewhere in the OT<br />

have been employed in the masculine in referring<br />

to the Divine Spirit, if that had been considered<br />

more appropriate.<br />

Let us also note the salient parallel between<br />

Isa 66:13 LXX and Jn 14:16:<br />

1 Nonetheless, the contrary grammatical gender can be used in order to<br />

obtain a determined cognitive effect— thus an ordained female may be<br />

called a ‘priest’ rather than a ‘priestess’, in order to emphasize an equality <strong>of</strong><br />

ecclesiastical rôle between the two sexes. ‘<strong>The</strong> metaphorical meanings <strong>of</strong><br />

sentences in which are used the masculine or the feminine <strong>of</strong> ... terms, [are]<br />

completely distinct’, Pedro José Chamizo Domínguez, Metáfora y<br />

conocimiento, Universidad de Málaga, 1998.<br />

257

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!