30.01.2013 Views

UPDATED - ColdType

UPDATED - ColdType

UPDATED - ColdType

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

EMBEDDED: WEAPONS OF MASS DECEPTION<br />

again; it’s the old story of overexposure and simplification<br />

driving out more nuanced coverage<br />

and follow-up. Leave it to the Guardian in England<br />

to spot the trend in America, reporting<br />

today:<br />

“One month after the beginning of the Iraqi<br />

conflict, America is returning to its normal diet<br />

of reality TV – including a presenting debut for<br />

one Monica Lewinsky.<br />

“Suddenly, it’s as if the war had never happened.<br />

Stefano Hatfield, a contributor to an<br />

advertising magazine explains: ‘War is God’s way<br />

of teaching Americans geography,’ said the<br />

writer Ambrose Bierce. Well, the war is apparently<br />

over because those lustrous locations,<br />

Brooklyn and Queens, have elbowed Baghdad<br />

and Umm Qasr out of the news.<br />

“The hour-long rightwing rant known as Fox<br />

News contained not a single Iraqi name check. Is<br />

it over then? As I look north out of my apartment<br />

window, I can just about make out the red, white<br />

and blue lighting on the Empire State Building<br />

through the clouds. It’s a giant Zoom ice lolly<br />

that will remain patriotically lit until ‘we’ had<br />

‘won.’ Or so we were told. It’s an eloquent symbol<br />

of the confusion reigning over how to define<br />

victory.<br />

“All around us, life has returned to what passes<br />

for normal. Scott Peterson, the platinum-blond<br />

husband who allegedly murdered and decapitated<br />

his pregnant wife, is the top story. The Central<br />

Park Jogger has a book out, Madonna a<br />

“controversial” new CD.<br />

While New York City has a budget crisis, the<br />

Yankees are laying waste to all around them.<br />

Michael Jordan has retired (again) and OJ Simpson<br />

is set to be an ‘expert’ commentator on<br />

Robert Blake’s murder trial.<br />

212<br />

Besting the West<br />

IT is not just Al-Jazeera by the way that has<br />

emerged with new respect in this war. Islam<br />

Online is carrying a report today from Cairo<br />

arguing “Western Media No Longer the Best.” It<br />

reads in part: “When the First Gulf War erupted<br />

in 1991, Egyptian TV was almost entirely dependent<br />

on CNN coverage of the war. The logo of the<br />

American news channel appeared on almost<br />

every feed about the war.<br />

“For many years Western media had represented<br />

the best option for Arab viewers. First, it<br />

possessed the necessary resources for high<br />

quality news coverage, resources that Arab<br />

media lacked. Secondly, it was generally viewed<br />

as being free and unconstrained by political considerations.<br />

It had gained a reputation of being<br />

motivated solely by professional incentives, in<br />

which the first and most important objective is to<br />

seek and present the truth as it is. This was in<br />

contrast to Arab media, which had gained a reputation<br />

of being a mere propaganda tool.<br />

“Now, with the outbreak of the Third Gulf War,<br />

things might be changing, and there is evidence<br />

to suggest that Western media might be losing<br />

its edge in the Arab world. “Several Arab satellite<br />

channels, notably Al Jazeera, Abu Dhabi TV,<br />

El Manar TV and possibly the new member of<br />

the MBC group, Arabiyya, have proven to have a<br />

high degree of technical and professional ability.”<br />

Was BBC biased?<br />

AND what about the western media? How well<br />

has it done? The Guardian today looks into the<br />

controversy about BBC coverage. Media

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!