Second Language Acquisition and Second ... - Stephen Krashen
Second Language Acquisition and Second ... - Stephen Krashen
Second Language Acquisition and Second ... - Stephen Krashen
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
Sentences, Paired Associates, <strong>and</strong> Spelling Clues) related to several "school-type" tests<br />
of French as a foreign language (reading, vocabulary, grammar, pronunciation accuracy,<br />
<strong>and</strong> phonetic discrimination). Gardner <strong>and</strong> Lambert (1959) presented evidence that<br />
"school French achievement", represented by grades in French as well as overall grades,<br />
is strongly related to performance on the Words in Sentences subtest of the MLAT,<br />
"suggesting that the student who is aware of grammatical distinctions in English will do<br />
well in French courses where the emphasis is on grammar" (p. 290). Gardner <strong>and</strong><br />
Lambert also found a "linguistic reasoning factor": scores on the MLAT related to<br />
achievement in reading French, a French grammar test, <strong>and</strong> a test of phonetic<br />
discrimination. While these studies were carried out in Canadian English-speaking<br />
situations (Montreal), Gardner <strong>and</strong> Lambert's subsequent research in the United States<br />
(Gardner <strong>and</strong> Lambert, 1972) confirms these findings.<br />
Gardner, Smythe, Clement, <strong>and</strong> Gliksman (1976) also confirmed that aptitude related<br />
much more to classroom skills (grades) than to communicative skills (speech) in French<br />
as a foreign language in grades 7 to 11 in various English-speaking communities in<br />
Canada. The effects of aptitude on performance in general was stronger for older<br />
students, a finding we shall return to later.<br />
Also of interest is Bialystok <strong>and</strong> Fröhlich (1977), who studied ninth- <strong>and</strong> tenth-graders<br />
studying French in Toronto. In one or two schools examined, aptitude correlated with<br />
self-reports of conscious monitoring (r = 0.55).<br />
Finally, recall that Carroll defined aptitude as rate of learning, that is, students with<br />
higher aptitude will appear to learn faster than students with lower aptitude. This<br />
predicts that aptitude will show its strongest effects in a short, well-taught course<br />
(Carroll, 1963). Note in this regard that conscious learning may provide a short-cut to<br />
performance in a second language. As mentioned elsewhere (<strong>Krashen</strong>, 1978b; <strong>Krashen</strong>,<br />
1977a), "learners" can use an acquisition-free mode of performance consisting of first<br />
language surface structure plus the Monitor. High-aptitude students should be more<br />
likely to be able to utilize this mode <strong>and</strong> thus may show more rapid initial progress.<br />
Over the long term, however, subconscious language acquisition is far superior, as the<br />
user of L1 surface structure plus the Monitor is<br />
25