Compilation Vol 3 Corrected (1-943).pmd - Goa Public Service ...

(xvii) Applicants claiming to have applied for the post of Motor
Vehicles Inspector in response to earlier notification of
1997 which was withdrawn and challenged the subsequent
notification of 2006 among others for not giving age
relaxation to the candidates who had applied earlier –
Applications dismissed mainly on the ground of limitation.
(xviii) Whether rejection of rural reservation claimed for not
producing the certificate in requisite form within the time
prescribed is correct? – Yes
(xix) Writ Petition filed against KAT order dated 11.4.2007
(pages 442 to 461 of this Compilation) is dismissed
holding that Govt. is entitled to conduct selection in
accordance with the changed rules and make final
recruitment - No candidate acquires any vested right
against the State - The State is entitled to withdraw the
notification by which it had previously notified recruitment
and issue fresh notification as per amended rules.
(xx) Whether the Commission can rectify the mistake regarding
production of reservation certificates after the provisional
select list is published? – Yes. Statutory provisions need to
be up held and estoppel cannot be allowed to come in its
way - An authority has inherent power to correct
inadvertent mistake.
(xxi) Whether non prescription of qualification or service for inservice
candidates vitiates the Rules – No. In-service
means all those who are in the service of the Department
including probationers - Applicants having participated in
the selection process not entitled to challenge the
Notification.
(xxii) Whether recruitment is bad for non-mentioning of date of
recruitment, number and date of Notification in the
Information Booklet? – No. An Advocate is an Officer of
the Court he should advise his clients to refrain from filing
frivolous case.
(xxiii) Whether Commission can prescribe additional criteria for
selection apart from the criteria prescribed under the
Recruitment Rules and whether the Commission can
change additional criteria at a later stage of the selection? -
No. In view of Rule 12 which prescribes only interview
prescribing written examination by fixing minimum marks
in each paper and fixing minimum marks at interview not
permissible.
xxxv
442 to 461
468 to 470
471 to 478
492 to 506
509 to 591
592 to 594
664 to 674