10.05.2012 Views

SECTION 1 -

SECTION 1 -

SECTION 1 -

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

There are no listed companies that conduct business exclusively in the services and<br />

employee benefits sector, but the following American listed companies were used on the basis of the<br />

criteria described above: Visa, MasterCard, Paychex and ADP. Although, based on their company<br />

profiles, none of these companies is exactly comparable to New Services, they nevertheless have the<br />

following similar features:<br />

• Visa and MasterCard are not exactly comparable to New Services because (i) they<br />

are only active in the payment sector and not in the employee and public benefits<br />

sector, and (ii) they do not operate with a structurally negative working capital<br />

balance which regularly generates financial revenue. However, their business<br />

model is similar to that of New Services for several reasons: (i) they use a “B2B”<br />

commission model and with no credit risk on the ultimate end user, (ii) they have a<br />

presence in numerous countries, (iii) their businesses are generally correlated with<br />

the growth of GDP, (iv) some of their growth is linked to the development of e‐<br />

money payment methods and online solutions, and (v) their revenue growth is<br />

derived from factors similar to those of New Services.<br />

• Paychex and ADP are also not exactly comparable to New Services because these<br />

companies offer services to companies of a different nature (mainly payroll<br />

management and human resources departments). However, their revenue sources,<br />

their presence in B2B markets, their underlying growth drivers (the relation to GDP<br />

and to the development of salaried employment in general) and their management<br />

of negative working capital requirements, generating financial revenues, may in<br />

some ways be considered similar to New Services.<br />

New Services generates negative working capital requirements that in turn generate financial<br />

proceeds on a recurring basis that are reported, pursuant to IFRS standards, in revenue, and<br />

accordingly as EBIT. The companies mentioned above that were chosen as potential comparables to<br />

New Services have no, or few, similar features, and furthermore are subject to U.S. GAAP. For this<br />

reason, to the extent that their application to comparable aggregates is not possible unless significant<br />

adjustments are made, the multiples established as the ratio between the enterprise value and the<br />

EBIT were not used. Revenue multiples were not used because they did not take into account<br />

different profitability levels of the companies included in the sample.<br />

Accordingly, only the Price Earning Ratios are mentioned in the chart below. This multiple is<br />

defined as of May 4, 2010 as (i) the average price at which the shares of the companies in question are<br />

traded over a period of 30 days and (ii) the net earnings per share published by each company (for<br />

2009) or resulting from the consensus of analysts’ forecasts concerning such companies (for 2010).<br />

Company<br />

PER 09A PER 10E<br />

ADP 16.5x 16.7x<br />

MasterCard 22.9x 18.9x<br />

Paychex 23.0x 22.6x<br />

Visa 27.2x 22.6x<br />

Note: Net EPS at December 31 for Automatic Data Processing (for the period ended June 30). Paychex (for the<br />

period ended May 31) and Visa (for the period ended September 30)<br />

Source: Datastream, CapIQ as at May 4, 2010, 10‐K annual reports and 10‐Q quarterly reports available on May<br />

4, 2010.<br />

130

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!