Sugarcane ethanol: Contributions to climate change - BAFF
Sugarcane ethanol: Contributions to climate change - BAFF
Sugarcane ethanol: Contributions to climate change - BAFF
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
3.4. Other effects<br />
•<br />
Why are current food prices so high?<br />
USD ex<strong>change</strong> rate developments. World prices are denominated in dollars and the<br />
dollar depreciated against most currencies. �e increase in prices in other currencies<br />
is therefore much less.<br />
Speculation:<br />
• In recent months spot and future prices do not fully converge.<br />
• Future prices remain higher than prices on spot markets.<br />
– Reason for this development:<br />
› Most hedging (90%) is Index-hedging, i.e. ‘traditional’ short- and long hedging<br />
does not dominate the price development in the future markets.<br />
› �us, if everybody expects high prices, then future prices tend <strong>to</strong> be higher than<br />
the spot prices.<br />
– So, part of current high prices can be attributed <strong>to</strong> this ‘bubble’.<br />
• Di�cult <strong>to</strong> estimate the impact of speculation in this s<strong>to</strong>ry.<br />
– �e crises on the �nancial markets are diverting funds away from traditional<br />
�nancial institutions leading <strong>to</strong> a large pool of funds available for investments in<br />
other markets.<br />
– �ere is de�nitely a impact of speculation in current high prices<br />
– Hard <strong>to</strong> say it makes X %.<br />
– Growing volatility in food markets due <strong>to</strong> the fact that most of hedging is based on<br />
index funds and not anymore on the ‘traditional’ short and long hedging. �is share<br />
is less than 10% in <strong>to</strong>tal market volume.<br />
– An example for the current volatility: In the 1st week of March the �uctuation of<br />
maize prices was more than 150 USD/t, which is more than last year’s average maize<br />
price!<br />
• Impact of speculation on current spike in agricultural prices is di�cult <strong>to</strong> quantify.<br />
Figure 10 shows the composition of the maize futures markets broken down between<br />
commercial merchants, managed money funds and commodity index traders <strong>to</strong>gether<br />
with the price development in USD per bushel of maize (right-hand scale).<br />
– It clearly shows that not only the ‘speculative’ index and fund hedging but also the<br />
increase in short futures by commercial merchants contributed <strong>to</strong> the dramatic<br />
increase in maize future prices.<br />
– However, the managed money funds which are mostly pension funds – which<br />
diversify their portfolio now also <strong>to</strong> agricultural commodities – cut down their<br />
purchase of additional contracts on long position when prices increased dramatically<br />
(Figure 10).<br />
–<br />
A formal assessment is hampered by data and methodological problems, including<br />
the di�culty of identifying speculative and hedging-related trades.<br />
<strong>Sugarcane</strong> <strong>ethanol</strong> 237