08.01.2013 Views

Sugarcane ethanol: Contributions to climate change - BAFF

Sugarcane ethanol: Contributions to climate change - BAFF

Sugarcane ethanol: Contributions to climate change - BAFF

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

3.4. Other effects<br />

•<br />

Why are current food prices so high?<br />

USD ex<strong>change</strong> rate developments. World prices are denominated in dollars and the<br />

dollar depreciated against most currencies. �e increase in prices in other currencies<br />

is therefore much less.<br />

Speculation:<br />

• In recent months spot and future prices do not fully converge.<br />

• Future prices remain higher than prices on spot markets.<br />

– Reason for this development:<br />

› Most hedging (90%) is Index-hedging, i.e. ‘traditional’ short- and long hedging<br />

does not dominate the price development in the future markets.<br />

› �us, if everybody expects high prices, then future prices tend <strong>to</strong> be higher than<br />

the spot prices.<br />

– So, part of current high prices can be attributed <strong>to</strong> this ‘bubble’.<br />

• Di�cult <strong>to</strong> estimate the impact of speculation in this s<strong>to</strong>ry.<br />

– �e crises on the �nancial markets are diverting funds away from traditional<br />

�nancial institutions leading <strong>to</strong> a large pool of funds available for investments in<br />

other markets.<br />

– �ere is de�nitely a impact of speculation in current high prices<br />

– Hard <strong>to</strong> say it makes X %.<br />

– Growing volatility in food markets due <strong>to</strong> the fact that most of hedging is based on<br />

index funds and not anymore on the ‘traditional’ short and long hedging. �is share<br />

is less than 10% in <strong>to</strong>tal market volume.<br />

– An example for the current volatility: In the 1st week of March the �uctuation of<br />

maize prices was more than 150 USD/t, which is more than last year’s average maize<br />

price!<br />

• Impact of speculation on current spike in agricultural prices is di�cult <strong>to</strong> quantify.<br />

Figure 10 shows the composition of the maize futures markets broken down between<br />

commercial merchants, managed money funds and commodity index traders <strong>to</strong>gether<br />

with the price development in USD per bushel of maize (right-hand scale).<br />

– It clearly shows that not only the ‘speculative’ index and fund hedging but also the<br />

increase in short futures by commercial merchants contributed <strong>to</strong> the dramatic<br />

increase in maize future prices.<br />

– However, the managed money funds which are mostly pension funds – which<br />

diversify their portfolio now also <strong>to</strong> agricultural commodities – cut down their<br />

purchase of additional contracts on long position when prices increased dramatically<br />

(Figure 10).<br />

–<br />

A formal assessment is hampered by data and methodological problems, including<br />

the di�culty of identifying speculative and hedging-related trades.<br />

<strong>Sugarcane</strong> <strong>ethanol</strong> 237

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!