10.01.2013 Views

ComputerAided_Design_Engineering_amp_Manufactur.pdf

ComputerAided_Design_Engineering_amp_Manufactur.pdf

ComputerAided_Design_Engineering_amp_Manufactur.pdf

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

TABLE 6.1<br />

Pre-Adoption Issues<br />

Issues of CAD Adoption<br />

Stage Question Issues<br />

Pre-Adoption 1. What is the feasibility<br />

of training?<br />

2. How to gain expected<br />

benefits?<br />

3. How will it impact<br />

work flow?<br />

What is an estimation of<br />

cost?<br />

When to give training?<br />

Where to get training?<br />

Who needs training?<br />

Are funds available?<br />

Worker attitudes<br />

Worker morale<br />

Worker skills<br />

Implementation 1. What type of training? Formal or informal<br />

training?<br />

Off- or on-site?<br />

Vendor or consultant?<br />

Customized or generic?<br />

2. Who is to be trained? Skilled or semi-skilled<br />

workers?<br />

3. Will management be Supervisors or higher-level<br />

trained?<br />

managers?<br />

4. Is training included in<br />

What type of training can<br />

the budget?<br />

be afforded?<br />

Pre-adoption training issues often center around the tradeoffs between the anticipated out-of-pocket<br />

costs and the associated benefits of CAD. One of the primary managerial challenges is to assess accurately<br />

the training needs associated with the proposed CAD system and to convert them into a budget of cash<br />

expenditures. Some of the major factors that affect training costs are discussed in this section. They<br />

include: (1) determining the types and number of workers to be trained; (2) the technological aptitude<br />

or “trainability” of the workers; (3) the training method to be employed; and (4) the loss of productivity<br />

during the learning period. The benefits of CAD often include the expected cost savings or additional<br />

revenues accrued when the current methods are replaced by the proposed system. However, some<br />

anticipated benefits may be difficult to quantify accurately. For instance, dynamic market conditions can<br />

present a compelling justification for the need for a CAD system; the benefit may be survival through<br />

sustained competitiveness of the firm. On the other hand, problems with worker attitudes and morale<br />

can jeopardize the success of the implementation of the CAD system and create an opportunity cost with<br />

respect to unrealized benefits from the technology. These issues are discussed below.<br />

One major issue in the adoption decision is whether it is possible to re-train the present workforce to<br />

perform the tasks required under the new CAD system. This question involves examining both the<br />

“person” and “task” components of the training decision. 21 It is possible that the tasks and procedures<br />

used in the CAD system are so high level that some of the potential users may not possess the necessary<br />

skills and education to learn the new system within a reasonable time period. Worker receptivity may<br />

also be a problem if the existing workers exhibit non-adoptive behavior and decide that they are not<br />

interested in learning or using the new technology. Beatty and Gordon7<br />

found evidence of such non-adoptive<br />

behavior in certain instances of CAD implementation. Lack of worker support can jeopardize any hope of<br />

success in implementing the new CAD technology. It is critical, therefore, that the company accurately<br />

inventory its workers’ skills and abilities and assess workers’ attitudes toward using the new system.<br />

A company considering the adoption of a CAD system must also include an estimate of the total<br />

expense of educating the workforce. For ex<strong>amp</strong>le, the acquisition cost of a CAD system is much more<br />

than just the price of the computer hardware and software. A more complete estimate of expenses includes<br />

both training program expenses and a “cushion” for the loss of productivity experienced as employees

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!