Annual report 2006 - Dexia.com
Annual report 2006 - Dexia.com
Annual report 2006 - Dexia.com
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
CORPORATE GOVERNANCE<br />
MANAGEMENT REPORT<br />
COMPTES CONSOLIDÉS<br />
COMPTES SOCIAUX<br />
Activities of the Board of Directors<br />
In addition to the items belonging to the ordinary <strong>com</strong>petence<br />
of the Board of Directors (follow-up of the results, approval of<br />
the budget, appointment and <strong>com</strong>pensation of the members<br />
of the Management Board), the Board concentrated in<br />
particular on the following matters:<br />
• the definition of <strong>Dexia</strong>’s strategic direction over the next<br />
3, 5 and 10 year periods and <strong>com</strong>munication of the Group’s<br />
strategy;<br />
• the <strong>com</strong>position of the Board of Directors and its specialized<br />
sub<strong>com</strong>mittees;<br />
• the Board of Directors’ self-assessment process and<br />
the implementation of the specific re<strong>com</strong>mendations for<br />
improvement;<br />
• <strong>com</strong>pliance with the Lippens Code;<br />
• the criteria for independent directors;<br />
• the termination of private banking activities in the United<br />
Kingdom;<br />
• the sale of the Group’s ownership stake in Créatis;<br />
• the sale of Banque Artesia Nederland, Flexia, Belstar and<br />
<strong>Dexia</strong> Banque Privée France;<br />
• the review and approval of the 2005 audit plan;<br />
• the process for privatizing CEC;<br />
• the equity investment in Banca Comerciala Romana;<br />
• the acquisition of DenizBank;<br />
• the <strong>report</strong> from the Chairman of the Board of Directors of<br />
<strong>Dexia</strong> SA concerning the operations of the Board and the<br />
internal controls for the Group;<br />
• the discussion and reading of the internal audit <strong>report</strong> and<br />
the <strong>report</strong> on risk assessment and monitoring in 2005;<br />
• the monitoring of the <strong>Dexia</strong> Bank Nederland operation;<br />
• the status of various procedures underway in connection<br />
with the Lernout & Hauspie situation;<br />
• the discussion on <strong>Dexia</strong>’s positioning and strategic stake in<br />
the asset management area;<br />
• the shareholding program for employees and Group staff,<br />
as well as the <strong>2006</strong> stock option plan;<br />
• the strategy for the buy-back of the <strong>com</strong>pany’s treasury<br />
shares;<br />
• discussion on <strong>Dexia</strong>’s management policy for its strategic<br />
portfolio;<br />
• the evaluation of the Group’s new organization, which<br />
was implemented in <strong>2006</strong>, and the changes in the Group’s<br />
operational structure;<br />
• the discussion of the <strong>Dexia</strong> Group’s policies on<br />
subcontracting.<br />
Conflicts of interest in <strong>2006</strong><br />
As indicated previously, if a director has a proprietary interest<br />
that is directly or indirectly opposed to a decision or transaction<br />
that <strong>com</strong>es within the <strong>com</strong>petence of the Board of Directors,<br />
the director must notify the other Board members before the<br />
matter is discussed by the Board. In addition, both the Board<br />
member’s notification and the reasons justifying the conflicting<br />
interest included in the notification heading must be recorded<br />
in the minutes of the Board meeting during which a decision<br />
must be made regarding the matter in question.<br />
Below are extracts of the minutes of the Board of Directors’<br />
Meeting on March 2, <strong>2006</strong>, relating to the application of the<br />
provisions of Article 523 of the Belgian Company Code.<br />
During the meeting of March 2, <strong>2006</strong>, the Board considered<br />
the amount of <strong>com</strong>pensation to be paid to members of the<br />
Management Board. Since Axel Miller, the Chief Executive<br />
Officer, is also Chairman of the Management Board, and since<br />
the Board of Directors also decided the <strong>com</strong>pensation of Pierre<br />
Richard in his capacity as Chairman of the Management Board<br />
in 2005, these two individuals abstained (in <strong>com</strong>pliance with<br />
Article 523 of the Company Code) from participating in the<br />
Board of Directors’ deliberations and vote concerning their<br />
own <strong>com</strong>pensation. An excerpt of the minutes relating to the<br />
matters concerning Pierre Richard and Axel Miller is provided<br />
below.<br />
A. Variable <strong>com</strong>pensation 2005<br />
The Meeting of the Board of Directors in February 2005<br />
approved the principles for calculation of the variable<br />
<strong>com</strong>pensation 2005 of members of the Management Board.<br />
The criterion retained for calculation was the 2004/5 evolution<br />
of <strong>Dexia</strong> SA’s underlying net in<strong>com</strong>e* (the objective being<br />
to <strong>com</strong>pensate the ability of teams to respect the budget<br />
provided to that effect last year). The year 2005 now over, the<br />
Compensation Committee calculated and fixed the amount<br />
of variable <strong>com</strong>pensation 2005 for each member of the<br />
Management Board applying those principles.<br />
[...]<br />
It is proposed to grant Pierre Richard an amount of EUR 950,000<br />
and to grant Axel Miller an amount of EUR 587,080.<br />
*The 2004/2005 evolution of the underlying met in<strong>com</strong>e is +11.3%.<br />
[...].<br />
C. Variable <strong>com</strong>pensation <strong>2006</strong><br />
It has been observed that the former system for calculation of<br />
variable <strong>com</strong>pensation does not permit any individualization<br />
of personal situations (single formula applicable to all) and<br />
only resulted year after year in a rather relative variability (the<br />
result of the formula leading each year to percentages varying<br />
between 65% and 75%). The Compensation Committee<br />
therefore wishes to suggest a new system for calculation<br />
of the variable <strong>com</strong>pensation payable to members of the<br />
Management Board.<br />
The variable <strong>com</strong>pensation would be calculated according to<br />
three equally important criteria:<br />
• an initial Group criterion based on a formula linked to the<br />
results of <strong>Dexia</strong> SA which would be applicable in an identical<br />
manner to all the persons concerned;<br />
• a second criterion specific to the Management Board<br />
based on the achievement of (joint) objectives of members.<br />
Those objectives (for instance the <strong>com</strong>pletion of projects,<br />
levels of indicators of performance achieved, strategy<br />
implemented, priorities for <strong>2006</strong> and so on) would be fixed<br />
by the Compensation Committee on proposals from the<br />
Management Board;<br />
38 |<br />
<strong>Dexia</strong> / <strong>Annual</strong> Report <strong>2006</strong>