Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
2 .3<br />
spread <strong>of</strong> the Aramaic alphabet and language, which became the <strong>of</strong>ficial language and<br />
writing system for the administration <strong>of</strong> the state and for record keeping (as it did in<br />
Achaemenid Iran). At any rate, according to V.A. Livshits, a leading scholar in Iranian<br />
studies, the first examples <strong>of</strong> texts in ancient Khorezmian script, which is related to<br />
Aramaic, (or perhaps it is still Aramaic?) that have been found so far date back to the<br />
4th–3rd centuries BC.<br />
The creation <strong>of</strong> titles in southern Transoxiana followed a different process and<br />
was strongly connected to the emergence and development <strong>of</strong> the Kushan state.<br />
Titles <strong>of</strong> the rulers <strong>of</strong> this state were <strong>of</strong> Saka-Khotanese, Yuezhi, Greek, Bactrian and<br />
Chinese origin. According to Chinese records, the rulers <strong>of</strong> five Yuezhi possessions,<br />
which included Guishuang (Kuei-shuang, i.e. Kushan), used the title hsi-hou (xihou)<br />
or hi-heu, which, some scholars believe, is equivalent to the title shanyu, used by Hun<br />
(Xiongnu) and other rulers <strong>of</strong> nomadic tribes in Inner <strong>Asia</strong>. However, many scholars<br />
consider it equivalent to the title yabghu – a leader <strong>of</strong> nomadic tribes.<br />
Coins <strong>of</strong> Kushan (or Heraeus, as some scholars believe to be the issuer’s name) have<br />
the Greek title tyrannos (tyrant), comparable to the Etruscan ‘turan’ – ‘mistress, lady’,<br />
and therefore equivalent to the Aramaic MR’Y, which had the same meaning – ‘master’,<br />
‘lord’. At the same time, the title MR’Y, as we have demonstrated above, was used by the<br />
rulers <strong>of</strong> Bukhara and Southern Sogdia (and much later by Khorezmian rulers as well).<br />
Thus, the rulers <strong>of</strong> the different dominions that emerged in the 2nd–1st<br />
centuries BC in Transoxiana bore almost the same titles in terms <strong>of</strong> political<br />
significance, but the titles had different ethnic origins – Aramaic and Greek (MR’Y,<br />
MLK’ and tyrannos, basileus).<br />
According to J. Kennedy, the title tyrant found on the so-called Heraeus coinage<br />
reflects the vassal condition <strong>of</strong> its bearer, but in the Greek tradition, a tyrant was<br />
someone who forcibly seized power in a polis to establish sole rule and the fundamental<br />
characteristic <strong>of</strong> tyranny is one-person rule. In Greek history, alongside tyrants <strong>of</strong><br />
small, insignificant territories, are examples <strong>of</strong> tyrants who ruled large territories and<br />
possessed unlimited power. Examples are Peisistratus in Athens, Dionysius I and II,<br />
Hieron I and II <strong>of</strong> Syracuse, and the tyrants <strong>of</strong> Samos and Corinth.<br />
If this title was used for Kushan (Heraeus), then we can assume that the first<br />
Kushan ruler known to historians came to power by force and by subjugating other<br />
Yuezhi rulers. It would also suggest that the process <strong>of</strong> Yuezhi unification under<br />
Kushan rule began earlier than is recorded in Chinese texts, and also that it was not<br />
Kujula Kadphises who tried to create the first state <strong>of</strong> Kushan, but Kushan himself.<br />
The area <strong>of</strong> distribution <strong>of</strong> the Heraeus coins does not contradict this assumption;<br />
they were widespread throughout most <strong>of</strong> Bactria, especially in the east, and also in<br />
Gandhara. Kushan’s successor in the rise <strong>of</strong> the Kushan state, Kujula Kadphises, bore<br />
65