10.11.2014 Views

bQNs7mR

bQNs7mR

bQNs7mR

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

If you decide that you do want to sell some or all of the assets there are still, as Table A2 indicates, various legal<br />

protections that may prevent you from selling.<br />

Table A2: Potential protections that may be in place to prevent asset sales<br />

Potential protection<br />

Details<br />

Independent municipal<br />

corporation<br />

Restriction on collections given<br />

to cities<br />

Deed restrictions on assets gifted<br />

to a city<br />

Restrictive covenants on land<br />

sold to a city for use as an asset<br />

The collections that are part of anything that is structured as an independent municipal<br />

corporation are protected. A city may own the building but not the collections. Detroit’s<br />

public library collections fall into this category. Similarly, Minneapolis has its Park and<br />

Recreation Board, an independently elected, semi-autonomous body set up as a distinct<br />

entity to maintain and develop parks and protect them from the city council, mayor, and<br />

developers.<br />

Detroit Institute of Arts was privately founded in the 1880s, but the building, collection and<br />

endowment were given by cash-strapped founders to the city “in trust for the public." The<br />

Michigan attorney general has stated that the art in the DIA cannot be sold, although some<br />

lawyers have questioned whether a bankruptcy court will agree. If there ever were a sale,<br />

the public sector would probably have claim to some of the proceeds as a good deal of city,<br />

state, and metro-area funding has been sunk into the Institute.<br />

There may be deed restrictions on assets gifted to a city. For example, Eliza Howell Park in<br />

Detroit was deeded to the city of Detroit with the explicit caveat that it be maintained as a<br />

park. This can also be the case with individual art works.<br />

The land may have been sold to the city with a restrictive covenant that stipulated that the<br />

land only be used for municipal purposes. For example, Exxon Mobil sold land to the city<br />

of St. Paul for $1.00 with a restricted covenant requiring that the land (soon to be opened as<br />

Victoria Park) remain parkland in perpetuity.<br />

Appendix | 168

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!