14-1190b-innovation-managing-risk-evidence
14-1190b-innovation-managing-risk-evidence
14-1190b-innovation-managing-risk-evidence
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
CASE STUDY<br />
NANOMATERIALS<br />
Kamal Hossain (National Physical Laboratory)<br />
54<br />
‘Nanotechnologies’ describes a broad group of<br />
technologies that focus on the engineering<br />
and manipulation of materials at the<br />
nanoscale (1nm–100nm). At these scales, many<br />
materials exhibit novel properties<br />
that are not seen in their bulk forms.<br />
For example, quantum dots made of<br />
nanoscale semiconductor materials<br />
exhibit excellent and novel properties<br />
for display and lighting applications,<br />
and gold nanoparticles exhibit optical<br />
properties that make them excellent<br />
tools for medical imaging.<br />
In 2004, the Royal Society (RS) and<br />
the Royal Academy of Engineering<br />
(RAE) published the world leading<br />
report Nanoscience and nanotechnologies:<br />
opportunities and uncertainties 1 .<br />
This report acknowledged both<br />
the significant opportunities in<br />
nanotechnologies for UK industry,<br />
as well as the challenges that their<br />
development posed. As with the<br />
development of many emerging<br />
technologies, these challenges focused<br />
on uncertainties around <strong>risk</strong>s to health<br />
and the environment.<br />
Researchers had already begun<br />
to investigate the toxicology and<br />
environmental impact of a range of<br />
nano-objects prior to the publication<br />
of the 2004 report, which stimulated<br />
further investment. Between 2002<br />
and 2007, the UK alone invested<br />
over £150 million in research into<br />
the development and impact of<br />
nanotechnologies.<br />
Despite this investment, issues still<br />
remain. Conflicting results and differing<br />
scientific opinion mean regulators still<br />
cannot always make adequate <strong>risk</strong><br />
assessments and policymakers may<br />
lack the <strong>evidence</strong> to develop effective<br />
policy. For example, the European<br />
Commission’s Scientific Committee<br />
on Consumer Safety published its<br />
latest opinion on the use of nanoscale<br />
titanium dioxide in consumer<br />
products in 2013 (ref. 2), which stated that there were<br />
still uncertainties over the <strong>risk</strong> assessments used for<br />
nanomaterials, despite knowledge gaps being highlighted in<br />
the first opinion on the use of nanoscale titanium dioxide<br />
published 13 years ago.<br />
One reason for this continued<br />
uncertainty is largely due to an<br />
issue raised in the 2004 report: a<br />
“need to develop, standardize<br />
and validate methods<br />
of measurement of<br />
nanoparticles and<br />
nanotubes”. This<br />
100nm development is essential<br />
for the accurate<br />
quantification of any<br />
potential <strong>risk</strong>. In layman’s<br />
terms, you cannot<br />
measure the toxicological<br />
or environmental impact of a<br />
material if you don’t know what<br />
it is or how to measure it correctly.<br />
With UK government support,<br />
work is underway to address this<br />
issue. The National Physical Laboratory (NPL) is<br />
the UK’s centre of excellence in measurement<br />
research and represents the United Kingdom<br />
globally in measurement standards development.<br />
NPL undertakes research that aims to develop<br />
robust, repeatable measurement technologies and<br />
methods that can be applied reliably to understand,<br />
predict and manage potential <strong>risk</strong>s of engineered<br />
nanoscale materials. By removing uncertainty<br />
around the impact of nanotechnologies on health<br />
and the environment, this work benefits regulators,<br />
policymakers and industry by increasing confidence<br />
in policy decisions. NPL’s world-renowned expertise<br />
and work in nanoscale measurement is being applied<br />
to the development of international standards that<br />
UK industry can follow, helping the United Kingdom<br />
to maintain a leading position in the field.<br />
Foremost in these activities is the NPL’s<br />
work with the International Organisation for<br />
Standardisation (ISO) technical committee (TC)<br />
229 Nanotechnologies. The BSI (British Standards<br />
Institution), in close co-operation with NPL and UK<br />
industry, put forward the case for TC 229, which<br />
was formed in 2006 and is chaired by the United