here - College of Arts & Sciences - Bethel University

the debate, which means both Members have the responsibility to engage the other side’s
responses rather than just extend their partner’s analysis. Rebuttals should be a
comparison of the gov and opp philosophies, where they are in conflict, and what
standards should be used to determine which is best.
Flow – Good flowing is key for a good debate because it helps both sides track the
evolution of arguments. I keep a strict flow and try to protect both sides from new
arguments in rebuttals. That means it is important for you to tell me where you want me
to put your arguments on the flow. I do think that both sides should call points of order if
they think the issue is new and could influence the outcome of the debate.
Opp Strategy – I do not appreciate splitting the block. Like all theoretical issues – this is
potentially open to debate, but my bias is against it. I can’t see how having the opp go for
12 minutes of arguments, and then having the PMR answer those arguments in 5 minutes,
serves the educational purpose of debate.
Relative importance of presentation/communication skills to the critic in decision-making
:
Performance – Debate is about the oral clash in arguments, and I am more than a
glorified note-taker. Unless room logistics are prohibitive, I prefer that you stand to
speak.
Finally – Courtesy is very important to me in the debate. I like to see a highly charged
debating of the arguments, but do not like it when the clash over the arguments translates
into a clash between individuals. Treating each other with respect will keep heads cool
and lead to better arguments in the debate.
Relative importance of on-case argumentation to the critic in decision-making:
I like case arguments. See above for more detail.
Openness to critical/performative styles of debating:
I think utilizing these kinds of strategies comes with a unique set of costs and benefits.
While I may have a particular perspective about these strategies, I am open to listening to
them, and will decide based on arguments in the round. All the standards set up above
still apply.
Any additional comments:
All that being said – this is your activity. Play to your strengths and have fun.
164