08.01.2013 Views

roger wasson company - cheapersunglasses.com

roger wasson company - cheapersunglasses.com

roger wasson company - cheapersunglasses.com

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

Ghose, The Life Divine, Book II, Chapter XIV, for a modern<br />

exposition in this context.), and is popular in the Western world<br />

through the doctrines of Christian Science . The Augustinian solution that evil is a privation<br />

of essence or being (Footnote 90: Augustine, The Confessions<br />

of Saint Augustine, pp. 153, 154, et passim.) is likewise basically<br />

an illusionist theory of evil. For to say that everything<br />

that is, insofar as it is, is good, is to say no evil actually exists,<br />

which is precisely the allegation that evil has only an illusory<br />

existence. [[344]]<br />

By way of objection to this solution: the solution is selfcontradictory.<br />

First, because it is an indisputable fact that some<br />

evil exists; at least the evil of our thinking evil to exist when it<br />

does not---so that the proposition that all evil is illusory is thus<br />

false for the very reason that it is true, which is selfcontradictory.<br />

Second, to put the same point differently: if all<br />

evil is really illusory, then why is this offered as an explanation<br />

at all? If no evil exists, then it does not require explanation. If<br />

it does exist, then it is not illusory, in which case the original<br />

hypothesis is contravened.<br />

We may state our criticism more positively by saying that<br />

illusionism merely moves the problem of evil to another context:<br />

for the explanation of the origin and power of the illusion<br />

of evil is exactly as problematical as the explanation of evil itself.<br />

Evil then possesses at least an illusory reality, just as the<br />

mirage on the road is real as a mirage. And just as the mirage is<br />

not explained by calling it a mirage, neither is evil explained by<br />

calling it an illusion.<br />

Since illusionism thus reduces to self-contradiction, no solution<br />

to our problem is possible in terms of a denial that evil exists.<br />

Instrumentalism: the denial of evil’s ultimate character as<br />

evil, and the assertion that it is an instrument for good.---<br />

According to this particular approach to the problem, evil is de-

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!