07.03.2013 Views

A Beginner's View of Our Electric Universe - New

A Beginner's View of Our Electric Universe - New

A Beginner's View of Our Electric Universe - New

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

A directly associated issue is that comets are seen to come into the solar system from just about every direction<br />

in space. Because <strong>of</strong> this, astro-scientists now assume the existence <strong>of</strong> a ‘shell-like globe’ <strong>of</strong> lumps <strong>of</strong> ice that<br />

surrounds the whole solar system and that from within its population the origin <strong>of</strong> comets is likely very high.<br />

These assumptions have backfired somewhat and have generated further questions. The claims that comets are<br />

left over fragments from the formation <strong>of</strong> the solar system and that they can provide us with important clues about<br />

its origins have for some time been contradicted. This is because we are now told that comets could have been<br />

captured from other stars, a claim further added to by the statement that these comets now provide an opportunity<br />

for us to understand the likely composition <strong>of</strong> other stars. This makes me wonder how much wild speculation<br />

is being practiced and how much today's astro-science is<br />

being allowed to get away with. I hope you get a feeling<br />

for the easy willingness <strong>of</strong> astro-scientists to play with<br />

and alter their theories when unexpected new evidence<br />

and unwelcome problems come along. This is becoming<br />

a predictable model <strong>of</strong> behaviour today, especially among<br />

those who revel in the opportunity for personal exposure,<br />

either on TV or through other forms <strong>of</strong> media or through<br />

the books they write. This should, at the very least, make<br />

us wonder about the quality <strong>of</strong> information that has been<br />

supplied to us as ‘trustworthy and believable’.<br />

The Oort Cloud, Kuiper Belt and Asteroid Belt<br />

in relation to the Solar System © author<br />

Another claim <strong>of</strong> the standard comet model says that<br />

they are influenced to leave their stable orbits in the<br />

far away location <strong>of</strong> the 'Kuiper Belt' that is situated<br />

beyond the orbit <strong>of</strong> Neptune, or in the even further away<br />

Oort Cloud, by the gravitational influence <strong>of</strong> passing stars or through collisions with other companion bodies.<br />

However, some astute astronomers have observed that if this were true, then we should see many more comets<br />

in groups and not as the single visitors we do. To help picture here the unlikely nature <strong>of</strong> prediction versus actual<br />

observation, I will raise again the subject <strong>of</strong> scale, for it is important that we have an idea <strong>of</strong> the kind <strong>of</strong> distances<br />

and probabilities we are dealing with.<br />

I will give an easy to picture description regarding this model, one that was originally put together by astronomer<br />

Tom Van Flandern and which I saw quoted by Wallace Thornhill in one <strong>of</strong> his many excellent articles about<br />

comets, “Deep Impact 2” [3-3] on his website.<br />

42 | We are waiting for answers to these questions

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!