convergence
convergence
convergence
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
The Geography of Badness<br />
But surprisingly, given the central role these hubs play as both engines and enablers of<br />
illicit global commerce, there has been little rigorous empirical scholarship on how a city,<br />
country, or region becomes a black market mecca. 15 While there is hardly room here for the<br />
kind of sustained, methodical inquiry that is ultimately required, I will seek in this chapter to<br />
initiate a discussion of the geography of the illicit global economy by exploring what features<br />
make some places congenial to underworld actors and others not.<br />
The Role of Hubs in a Networked World<br />
It took a while for observers to grasp the revolution that has transformed global crime over the<br />
last few decades, but the study of globalized crime and illicit networks has gradually come into<br />
focus. One of the bedrock notions at the heart of this emerging field is the idea that a new breed<br />
of illicit, transnational, nonstate actors has been very busy in recent years, and that whether<br />
they are ideological terrorist groups or profit-driven criminals, they share certain characteristics<br />
at the level of their organizational DNA. They are networks. 16<br />
A decade ago, John Arquilla and David Ronfeldt described a new kind of nonhierarchical<br />
adversary: “dispersed organizations, small groups, and individuals who communicate, coordinate,<br />
and conduct their campaigns in an internetted manner, often without a precise central<br />
command.” 17 In the language of networks, each criminal actor came to represent a node in a<br />
dispersed associational map. The associations between these nodes can be described as links. 18<br />
Much of the early scholarship on illicit networks focused on the democratic character of<br />
these structures. Whereas traditional mafias, like nation-states, were entrenched and hierarchical,<br />
networks often had a flatter, more fluid, and adaptive leadership structure. This quality<br />
made them especially robust and difficult to attack because the removal of any one node in a<br />
criminal or terrorist network might have only a limited impact.<br />
Still, even in a decentralized network, all nodes are not created equal. Physicist Albert-László<br />
Barabási has shown that some nodes serve as points of connection for a disproportionate number<br />
of links. These nodes come to function as hubs. Imagine the difference between a map of the<br />
highways in the United States and a map of the air traffic routes. On the road map, cities are<br />
the nodes and the highways connecting them are the links. Each major city has at least one<br />
link to the highway system, but there are no cities served by hundreds of highways. So most of<br />
the nodes are fairly similar, with roughly the same number of links. But an airline map looks<br />
different. In order to operate efficiently, airlines route flights through certain hubs. So on a<br />
map of air traffic, a few specific nodes, such as Houston, Denver, or New York, will stand out<br />
with an exponentially larger number of links as they connect the vast majority of the airports<br />
around the country. 19<br />
In the same way Continental Airlines, Amazon.com, and United Parcel Service construct<br />
their delivery routes around a handful of critical hubs, black marketeers come to rely on some<br />
locations more than others. In some instances, this may simply be a matter of cultivating a few<br />
contacts on the ground in the jurisdiction in question who can make the relevant payments to<br />
ensure that a shipment of contraband passes through unmolested. But in other cases, criminal<br />
actors will come to base a large part of their business in these hubs, staging their shipments<br />
there, sourcing otherwise hard-to-come-by documentation, or laundering their money.<br />
99