untangling_the_web

DOClD: 4046925
UNCLASSIFIEDHFOR OFFICIAl YS~ g~JbY
unique to one engine. Only 2.6 percent of the results were shared by three
search providers, and 11.4 percent were delivered by two search engines." 33
I am not surprised by the results, although I doubt the lack of overlap is quite as
significant as the study indicates. The researchers used a relatively small sample,
they only looked at the top ten results, they included paid results, and-probably
most significantly-Dogpile sponsored the study. If a study to test metasearch
engine results compared to individual search engine results concludes that
metasearch engines do a better job, it is hardly surprising (and not necessarily
convincing).
You can read the Doqpile/University of Pittsburgh and Penn State University study
and take a look at Dogpile's "Compare Search Engines" page to see how the
comparison works.
Dogpile's Compare Search Engines
http://comparesearchengines.dogpile.com/
"Different Engines, Different Results"
http://comparesearchengines.dogpile.com/OverlapAnalysis.pdf
Rule Four
Use more than one search engine.
All search engines have their own way of doing things, which means there is no set
of rules or guidelines that users can apply to them all. It helps, however, to
familiarize yourself with the kinds of features available so you will at least know what
to look for.
Often research involves the search for specific information: a telephone number,
a name or title, a specific company or product, a piece of equipment, etc. Even
researching a general subject may require a broader data set than a virtual library or
subject guide offers if you need to find out as much as possible about a subject. For
example, if I need to know everything available on the web about Mexico and
NAFTA, I cannot limit myself to someone else's edited list. Besides, there won't be
33 Dogpile.com in collaboration with researchers from the University of Pittsburgh and Pennsylvania
State University, "Different Engines , Different Results, A Research Study," July 2005,
(14 November 2006). I have
serious doubts about the accuracy of this claim, but the general conclusion of the study that there is a
lack of overlap among search engine results is valid, if exaggerated.
44 UNCLASSIFIEDHFOR OFFICIAL l:JSE ONLY