Girls who like Boys who like Boys – Ethnography of ... - Yuuyami.com

Yuri also has a very particular taste in fanfiction and the fandoms that
she wishes to find fanfiction in. Consequently, she does not really follow other
fans’ fic recommendations, as she finds that many people will like certain fics,
which she doesn’t enjoy reading.
I only read PWP [plot? What plot? – sex-centered
fanfiction] when I’m at my wits’ end and there’s nothing
else to read. Even then I’m very, very picky. I hate fics that
have sex in them, I hate fics that say “I love you” and I hate
an abundance of kissing …especially in historical [settings]
such as in historical anime …pre-1940s essentially. So I
don’t like smut fics. I don’t really like yaoi, I like shounen
ai.
Yuri’s fandoms are mainly Japanese media based: when she speaks of hating
“I love you” fics and “kissing” in fics she is referring to the slew of anime fics
who use the Japanese phrase ai shiteru, a very emotional and deep way to say
“I love you” which a Japanese person would not use in any resemblance of
frequency, quite contrarily to the way fanfic authors display in their fiction.
Equally, before the 1940s kissing was not a common cultural custom in Japan,
and thus in a way is often an anachronistic plot movement. Maybe this would
be more tolerable to Yuri if her fandoms, in the sense of the source texts, were
placed in the contemporary, but as it is, Saiyuki is placed in a semi-fantastical
but roughly medieval Chinese setting while Rurouni Kenshin deals with the
Meiji restoration.
When she specifies that she doesn’t like to read yaoi, but prefers
shounen ai, Yuri is reiterating once again that she does not enjoy reading sexcentered
fics as much as other genres: she prefers “boys’ love” to “no peak, no
98