02.02.2015 Views

SumerianGrammar

SumerianGrammar

SumerianGrammar

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

DETERMINATION, SPECIFICATION<br />

51<br />

nesû adj. lex. for Nabnìtu X 36 (MSL 16, 118: IX (= X) 36 where<br />

it is read dal) and Aa II/7: 11' (MSL 14, 293: ri-i = né-su-ú).<br />

-ri is mainly found in the phrase u 4 -/∞gi 6 -/mu-ri(-a) “in those<br />

days/nights/years” when the poet refers to beginning in primordial<br />

time; cf. already OS TS” 79 i 1–5 (UD.GAL.NUN text). -ri-a may<br />

be analysed either as [ri] + locative case particle -a or as [ri] + -a<br />

of ¢am†u participle, with the locative not further noted in spelling.<br />

Note: Shaffer 1963, 122, referred to SBH no. 4:162 f. etc. u 4 -RI-LI-na (= ina<br />

ùmè ullùti “in those days”) and he preferred reading u 4 -re-èn-na instead of u 4 -dalle-na,<br />

from which Attinger 1993, 176, deduces a pair “-re/i, -re-èn”. The topic<br />

must be left to further research.<br />

Note: Yoshikawa 1993, 185–92, tried to show there was a “Spatial Deictic System<br />

in Sumerian”, with -e “something in the space which is close to the speaker and<br />

addressee” and -ri “something which is remote from the space occupied by the<br />

speaker or addressee”. Yoshikawa essentially bases himself on lexical texts, not<br />

on context examples.<br />

7.5. -“e()<br />

-“e occurs in lú-“e in Gilgame“ and Agga 69–71, 91–92 referring to<br />

Gilgame“ seen on the Uruk city wall by beleaguering Agga. Jacobsen<br />

1965, 177 fn. 55, tentatively proposed “anyone from here” basing<br />

himself on NGBT II i 11–15 (MSL 4, 158 f.) where, however, only<br />

line 11 [lú-“]e = animmamû can be restored more or less reliably. Katz<br />

1993, 43, 45 offers “that person”; Römer 1980 lines 91 f. lú-“e “der<br />

Mann da”.<br />

So, due to the extreme scarcity of attestation, -“e is not a certain<br />

candidate for inclusion among the demonstrative particles.<br />

7.6. Recapitulation<br />

To sum up, out of the five elements discussed here, -ne(n), -bi, -e,<br />

-ri, and -“e, only two: -ne(n) and -bi, may be convincingly classified<br />

as demonstrative particles.

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!