01.10.2014 Views

Brand Relevance: Making Competitors Irrelevant - always yours

Brand Relevance: Making Competitors Irrelevant - always yours

Brand Relevance: Making Competitors Irrelevant - always yours

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

THE FOOD INDUSTRY ADAPTS 141<br />

vigorously argued that Frito - Lay was deliberately deceiving<br />

consumers into believing that the snacks no longer contained<br />

Olean (Olestra).<br />

P & G essentially gave up in 2002, selling the factory to a<br />

supplier fi rm and writing off a substantial plant investment,<br />

although they did retain the brand and technology rights.<br />

Further, Frito - Lay and P & G ’ s Pringles continued to use Olean<br />

(Olestra) under the Light subbrand. Presumably those customers<br />

who experience side effects have learned not to use Olean,<br />

and the remainder can enjoy its benefi ts. In addition, there<br />

was a technological spin - off application that resulted in P & G ’ s<br />

2009 introduction of a paint additive using an Olestra - like<br />

substance with several good qualities, including the absence of<br />

toxic fumes.<br />

In retrospect, the Olestra adventure cost P & G hundreds of<br />

millions of dollars and diverted resources from more productive<br />

options. P & G may have overestimated the appeal of the product<br />

and did not accept or take seriously enough the negatives<br />

or the infl uence of CSPI. However, given the unquestioned size<br />

and urgency of the problem to fi nd a low - calorie, functional fat<br />

substitute and the competitive advantages for P & G had Olestra<br />

worked, there was an enormous upside, and the gamble must<br />

have been temping. There needs to be a distinction between<br />

good decisions and good outcomes. This is a case in which there<br />

might have been a good decision but a bad outcome.<br />

From Fat to Health<br />

Fats are not the only story in healthy eating. There have been<br />

a lot more chapters and characters. Among the most prominent<br />

healthy eating suggestions have been to reduce the intake<br />

of carbs, sodium, sugar, and, for some, glutens while increasing<br />

incidence in the diet of whole grains, fi ber, soy, protein, probiotic<br />

cultures, vitamins, and fi sh oil, and to use food products<br />

that are natural and organic. These thirteen dimensions of food,

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!