Graham R (Ed.) - Anarchism - A Documentary History of Libertarian Ideas Volume One - From Anarchy to Anarchism (300 CE to 1939)

102/ ANARCHISM
deal effectively with all the manifold problems generated by the Revolution. For every
dictatorship, be it exercised by an individual or collectively by relatively few individuals,
is necessarily very circumscribed, very shortsighted, and its limited
perception cannot, therefore, penetrate the depth and encompass the whole COI11-
plex range of popular life ...
What should the revolutionary authorities-and there should be as few of them
as possible-do to organize and spread the Revolution They must promote the Revolution
not by issuing decrees but by stirring the masses to action. They must under
no circumstances fo ist any artificial organization whatsoever upon the masses. On
the contrary, they should foster the self-organization of the masses into autonomolls
bodies, federated from the bottom upward ...
1 regard the Prussian invasion as a piece of good fo rtune fo r France and for
world revolution. lfthis invasion had not taken place, and if the revolution in France
had been made without it, the French socialists themselves would have attempted
once again-and this time on their own account-to stage a state revolution [coup
d'etat[. This would be absolutely illogical, it would be fatal fo r socialism; but they certainly
would have tried to do it, so deeply have they been influenced by the principles
of Jacobinism. Consequently, among other measures of public safety decreed by a
convention of delegates from the cities, they would no doubt try to impose communism
or collectivism on the peasants. This would spark an armed rebellion. which
would be obliged to depend upon an immense, well-disciplined, and well-organized
army. As a result, the socialist rulers would not only give another army of rebellious
peasants to the reaction, they would also beget the fo rmation ofa reactionaiY mililarist
caste of power-hungry generals within their own ranks. Thus replenished, the
machinery of the State would soon have to have a leader, a dictator, an emperor, to
direct this machine. All this would be inevitable, fo r it springs not from the caprice of
an individual but from the logic of the situation, a logic that never errs.
Fortunately, events themselves will now force the urban workers to open their
eyes and reject this fatal procedure copied from the Jacobins. Under the prevailing
circumstances, only madmen would even dream of unleashing a reign of terror
against the countryside. If the countryside should rise up against the cities, the cities,
and France with them, would be lost. ..
But my dear friends, we are not lost. France can be saved by anarchy.
Let loose this mass anarchy in the countryside as well as in the cities, aggravate
it until it swells like a furious avalanche destroying and devouring everything in its
path, both internal enemies and Prussians. This is a bold and desperate measure, I