MAGICAL MEDICINE: HOW TO MAKE AN ILLNESS ... - Invest in ME
MAGICAL MEDICINE: HOW TO MAKE AN ILLNESS ... - Invest in ME
MAGICAL MEDICINE: HOW TO MAKE AN ILLNESS ... - Invest in ME
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
29<br />
Professor Anthony David’s response to this was notable; he stated that Altmann et al’s result overlooked<br />
“the bias <strong>in</strong>herent <strong>in</strong> self‐selection of cases” and “the cases may already have had unexpla<strong>in</strong>ed symptoms and cognitive<br />
problems”. Anthony David (Professor of Cognitive Neuropsychiatry at Guy’s K<strong>in</strong>g’s and Thomas’ School of<br />
Medic<strong>in</strong>e, where he works with Wessely) also said: “The reopen<strong>in</strong>g of the Camelford case is regrettable as the<br />
people concerned may worry anew about their health” (BMJ 2000:320:1337).<br />
The death toll has s<strong>in</strong>ce risen – see The Daily Telegraph, 20 th April 2006: “Alzheimer’s fear grips poisoned water<br />
town” by Medical Editor Celia Hall.<br />
More recently, Exley and Esiri described severe cerebral congophilic angiopathy co<strong>in</strong>cident with <strong>in</strong>creased<br />
bra<strong>in</strong> alum<strong>in</strong>ium <strong>in</strong> a resident of Camelford (JNNP 2006: doi:10.1136/jnnp.2005.086553), caus<strong>in</strong>g Walter<br />
Lukiw, Associate Professor of Neuroscience at Louisiana State University Health Sciences Centre, to note<br />
that as over‐expression of stress‐sens<strong>in</strong>g, pro‐<strong>in</strong>flammatory and pro‐apoptotic genes have been observed <strong>in</strong><br />
alum<strong>in</strong>ium sulphate‐<strong>in</strong>duced neurotoxicity, “careful attention should be paid to the neurological status and<br />
neuropathological outcome of the thousands of unfortunate victims at Camelford” (eBMJ, 21 st April 2006).<br />
Professor Margaret Esiri is one of the country’s lead<strong>in</strong>g neuropathologists, and Dr Chris Exley is an expert <strong>in</strong><br />
alum<strong>in</strong>ium exposure.<br />
In December 2007, the West Somerset Coroner Michael Rose ordered the police to re‐open the Camelford<br />
pollution case follow<strong>in</strong>g allegations of a cover‐up (Guardian, 13 th December 2007; also reported by BBC<br />
News: http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/england/cornwall/7142515.stm ).<br />
Respond<strong>in</strong>g to this announcement, Sue Waddle, spokesperson for the charity <strong>ME</strong> Research UK, a magistrate<br />
and the mother of a daughter severely affected by <strong>ME</strong>, wrote to The Guardian on 16 th December 2007: “I and<br />
many others await with <strong>in</strong>terest the outcome of any police <strong>in</strong>quiry. A 1995 paper by two psychiatrists asserted that<br />
mass hysteria and / or anxiety were responsible for the supposed suffer<strong>in</strong>g of those <strong>in</strong> the Camelford area at the time.<br />
(One of these ‘experts’) has also given his expert op<strong>in</strong>ion on many other ‘non‐illnesses’ and ‘unfounded health worries’.<br />
He happens to be the Government expert on electricity pylons, mobile phone masts, Gulf War Syndrome and myalgic<br />
encephalomyelitis. What has prompted the Coroner’s call for an <strong>in</strong>quiry is irrefutable, empirical evidence from the<br />
organs of some of the victims who have died. I cannot see how psychological problems can cause the build up of<br />
enormous amounts of alum<strong>in</strong>ium <strong>in</strong> the bra<strong>in</strong> – much less viral <strong>in</strong>fection <strong>in</strong> the sp<strong>in</strong>al cord of victims of <strong>ME</strong>”.<br />
In February 2009, follow<strong>in</strong>g a FOIA request, it was reported that the Coroner warned M<strong>in</strong>isters of the<br />
“serious political consequences” of not assist<strong>in</strong>g his <strong>in</strong>quiry. In a letter request<strong>in</strong>g £110,000 for further medical<br />
research, Coroner Michael Rose told Health Secretary Alan Johnson MP that he was “fearful for the<br />
ramifications once it becomes known that the lives of thousands <strong>in</strong> Cornwall are put <strong>in</strong> jeopardy…”. The M<strong>in</strong>ister,<br />
Ben Bradshaw MP, took three months to respond to the Coroner, whose request was refused by the<br />
Department of Health. From letters released to the Western Morn<strong>in</strong>g News, it is known that Mr Bradshaw<br />
urged the Coroner to “reconsider” his (Mr Bradshaw’s) request for the publication of a Government‐ordered<br />
Report <strong>in</strong>to the long‐term health effects of the <strong>in</strong>cident to be delayed but the Health M<strong>in</strong>ister was not to be<br />
moved: “We have mechanisms to fund policy‐related research, but such work is commissioned by issu<strong>in</strong>g a call for<br />
proposals for research to address the problem at hand and tender<strong>in</strong>g. We then use peer review to commission the most<br />
appropriate and promis<strong>in</strong>g proposal”. The Coroner responded: “I do not say this lightly….but can you imag<strong>in</strong>e<br />
anyth<strong>in</strong>g more prejudicial to a Government‐backed review deny<strong>in</strong>g that there was any health risk when the jury may be<br />
asked to accept the evidence of one of the country’s lead<strong>in</strong>g neuropathologists (Professor Margaret Esiri) who may say<br />
the opposite?” (http://www.thisisnorthdevon.co.uk/northdevonsurf<strong>in</strong>g/news/Water‐poison‐research‐needs‐<br />
fund<strong>in</strong>g/article‐664972‐detail/article.html).<br />
Clearly the medical evidence did not support David and Wessely’s beliefs that the Camelford disaster was<br />
merely contagious mass hysteria, any more than it supports the Wessely School’s notion that <strong>ME</strong>/CFS is