The Earle family : Ralph Earle and his descendants

386 THE EARLE FAMILY [EIGHTH
Their children were :
3504-1. Marian E. Merrill, b. Nov. 14, 1869.
3505-2. Nina E. Merrill, b. Jan. I, 1872.
3506-3. Carl A. Merrill, b. Jan. 2, 1880.
[2310-1]. Elizabeth 8 D. Earl (Benjamin? A., William, 6
Robert,* William,* John,* William, 2 Ralph 1
), dau. of
Benjamin A. and Jane V. (Dickson) Earl, b. May 22,
1853, in Cincinnati, Ohio: m. Oct. 30, 1873, Benson
P. Cooper, of Nashua, N. H., and lives in Philadelphia,
Pa.
Their children were :
3507-1. Warren Earl Cooper, b. Aug. 3, 1874.
3508-2. Benson Maynard Cooper, b. Oct. 22, 1877 ; d. Feb. 21,
187S.
3509-3. Ralph Stuart Cooper, b. Oct. 22, 1879.
3510-4. Gertrude Van Zandt Cooper, b. Dec. 21, 18S4; d.
Feb. 23, 1885.
351 1-5. Elizabeth Cooper, b. April 24, 1887.
55
[2313-1]. William Henry
Earl (Pauls William, 6
Robert,,5 William.* John,* William, 2 Ralph 1
), son of
Paul and Larosiere E. (Howes) Earl, b. Sept. 18, 1845,
in Dennis, Mass. ; tn. Sept. 22, 1870, in Sandwich, Mass.,
Mary Anna Thorns,
Portsmouth, Va.
of Dundee, Scotland, and lives in
Their children were :
35 1 2-1. William Howes Earl, b. June 13, 1S71, at Sandwich.
3513-2. Anna Gertrude Virginia Earl, b. Dec. 5, 18S3, at
Portsmouth.
[2335-2]. Antoinette 8 Earl (Alfred,'' Oliver, 6 Raul,*
William,* John,s William, 2 Ralph 1
), dau. of Alfred and
Caroline (Mills) Earl, b. Nov. 24, 1854, m Gloversville,
N. Y. ; m. July 25, 1874, Charles A. Crosby, and lives
in Belding, Ionia Co., Mich.