23.12.2014 Views

Untitled

Untitled

Untitled

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

K. TOTLADZE, GAPS OF THE LAW OF GEORGIA “ON INTERNATIONAL TREATIES OF GEORGIA”<br />

Ministers. Consequently, all bodies of the Government<br />

including Ministries as well as the<br />

State Ministers shouid have the right to submit<br />

a proposal on the conclusion of international<br />

treaty.<br />

The proposal shall be submitted to the<br />

Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Georgia, the latter<br />

submits these proposals to the Ministry of<br />

Justice of Georgia for conclusion on the compatibility<br />

of a treaty with the legislation of Georgia<br />

and on possible legal effects, to the Ministry<br />

of Finance – for the conclusion on possible<br />

financial-economic outcomes of a treaty<br />

and also to the relevant central body of executive<br />

authority. 9 In practice, the abovementioned<br />

procedure is extended in time and is<br />

rather complicated, since the interpretation of<br />

the general provision of law is made in a different<br />

ways by the Ministries and the Administration<br />

of the President. In order to increase<br />

the role of the Ministries as the lobbies of a<br />

treaty within their competence and to simplify<br />

the abovementioned procedure, the proposals<br />

of different Ministries submitted to the Ministry<br />

of Foreign Affairs shall be comprehensive<br />

and include the following: a) text of the<br />

international treaty in Georgian language;<br />

b) explanatory memorandum; c) opinion of the<br />

Ministry of Foreign Affairs on possible foreign<br />

political outcomes of International treaty;<br />

d) opinions of the Ministry of Justice on the<br />

compatibility of a treaty with the legislation of<br />

Georgia and on possible legal effects and in<br />

case of necessity draft law on amendments<br />

and addenda into the normative acts of Georgia;<br />

e) opinion of the Ministry of Finance on<br />

possible financial-economic outcomes of a<br />

treaty; f) opinion of relevant competent authority/authorities;<br />

g) paper of agreement including<br />

well-grounded arguments on acceptance<br />

or non acceptance of these opinions; h) name<br />

of the Ministry/Ministries responsible for the<br />

implementation of a treaty (whole package).<br />

On the bases of final analysis of the Ministry<br />

of Foreign Affairs this package shall be presented<br />

to the Administration of the President,<br />

which will reinforce the role of the Ministry of<br />

Foreign Affairs as a central authority for making<br />

political decisions. It is important to be<br />

mentione that the proposal on conclusion of<br />

intergovernmental treaty shouldl be submitted<br />

to the Prime Minister of Georgia.<br />

6. ACCEPTANCE OF INTERNATIONAL<br />

TREATY, AS ONE OF THE FORMS OF<br />

CONSENT TO BE BOUND BY A TREATY<br />

Existing current legislation does not provide<br />

for acceptana asa form of expression of consent<br />

to be bound by treaty .<br />

Acceptance of international treaty is a resent<br />

form of the consent of the State to be<br />

bound by a treaty. However, innovation is rather<br />

terminological then conceptual, which is<br />

proved by a treaty practice of the States and<br />

the fact that the same procedure in one case<br />

is considered as acceptance of a treaty and<br />

in other cases as accession to a treaty. For<br />

example, the Constitution of UNESCO provides<br />

for that the States may accede to the Constitution<br />

through its acceptance, 10 which shall be<br />

done by delivering the official document on<br />

the acceptance of a treaty to the Secretary<br />

General of the UN.<br />

In some cases the acceptance of a treaty<br />

may be applied instead of the ratification. This<br />

is possible when international treaty by to its<br />

goal and objective is not the subject to ratification.<br />

Mostly the term "acceptance" is included<br />

into the text of a treaty, as an alternative<br />

form of consent of a State to be bound by a<br />

treaty.<br />

Acceptance as well as approval shall be<br />

formed documentary. In opposite to the ratification<br />

instrument, document of the acceptance<br />

and approval does not have clearly determined<br />

form. Generally it is a letter or verbal<br />

note, which on behalf of the Government<br />

is signed by the Minister of Foreign Affairs or<br />

its deputy, although even in this case it is possible<br />

to exchange these documents or submit<br />

them to the depository for the filing. 11<br />

In a view of proper implementation of Article<br />

14 of the (1969) Vienna Convention "on<br />

the Law of Treaty" in practice, and considering<br />

the fact that multilateral international treaties<br />

often provide for the acceptance as one<br />

of the forms of consent of the State to be<br />

bound by a treaty, it is essential to establish<br />

particular legal mechanism by Georgian domestic<br />

legislation and to define which State<br />

shall have authority to accept international<br />

treaty as a form of consent of the State to be<br />

bound by a treaty.<br />

201

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!