10.07.2015 Views

Los retos de la historia oral en el siglo XXI: diversidades ...

Los retos de la historia oral en el siglo XXI: diversidades ...

Los retos de la historia oral en el siglo XXI: diversidades ...

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

Sesiones parale<strong>la</strong>s / Parall<strong>el</strong> sessionsSubtema / Subteme 14Memoria, <strong>historia</strong> <strong>oral</strong> y comunidad / Memory, OralHistory and community14 a. Cre<strong>en</strong>cias compartidas, tradiciones r<strong>el</strong>igiosasy transmisión <strong>oral</strong>. Shared B<strong>el</strong>iefs, R<strong>el</strong>igiousTraditions, and the Oral Transmission.14b- Culturas no hegemónicas e <strong>historia</strong> <strong>oral</strong> /Nohegemoniccultures and Oral HistorySa<strong>la</strong> Meyer Dubrovsky - Mesa / Session 62Coordinan / Chair: Andrea Molinari——————————————————————————————————————————————SILVA SALINAS, Cami<strong>la</strong>Educación, proyecto social y po<strong>de</strong>r: La experi<strong>en</strong>cia<strong>de</strong> <strong>la</strong>s escue<strong>la</strong>s y jardines infantiles autogestionados<strong>de</strong> La Victoria, B<strong>la</strong>nqueado y Nueva La Habana. Santiago<strong>de</strong> Chile, 1957-1973El objetivo <strong>de</strong> <strong>la</strong> pon<strong>en</strong>cia es dar cu<strong>en</strong>ta <strong>de</strong> <strong>la</strong>s proyecciones políticas, socialesy culturales <strong>de</strong> una serie <strong>de</strong> experi<strong>en</strong>cias educativas autogestionadas por lossectores popu<strong>la</strong>res urbanos <strong>en</strong>tre 1957 y 1973 <strong>en</strong> Santiago <strong>de</strong> Chile, <strong>en</strong> <strong>el</strong> marco<strong>de</strong>l proceso <strong>de</strong> movilización política que <strong>de</strong>sembocó <strong>en</strong> <strong>el</strong> gobierno <strong>de</strong> <strong>la</strong> UnidadPopu<strong>la</strong>r. Para <strong>el</strong>lo se analizarán tres casos <strong>en</strong> que escue<strong>la</strong>s primarias fueronconstruidos y administrados por pob<strong>la</strong>dores o ‘pobres <strong>de</strong> <strong>la</strong> ciudad’, g<strong>en</strong>erándosediversas formas <strong>de</strong> re<strong>la</strong>ción <strong>en</strong>tre comunidad, escue<strong>la</strong> y Estado, atravesadaspor <strong>el</strong> proceso político <strong>en</strong> <strong>de</strong>sarrollo. A través <strong>de</strong> <strong>la</strong>s memorias <strong>de</strong> ex alumnos,apo<strong>de</strong>rados y doc<strong>en</strong>tes, se busca dar cu<strong>en</strong>ta <strong>de</strong> <strong>la</strong>s experi<strong>en</strong>cias educativas <strong>de</strong><strong>la</strong>s escue<strong>la</strong>s básicas <strong>de</strong> <strong>la</strong>s pob<strong>la</strong>ciones La Victoria <strong>de</strong> 1958, B<strong>la</strong>nqueado <strong>de</strong> 1968y <strong>de</strong>l campam<strong>en</strong>to Nueva Habana <strong>de</strong> 1971, con <strong>el</strong> fin <strong>de</strong> analizar los fundam<strong>en</strong>tosculturales <strong>de</strong> <strong>la</strong>s propuestas educativas <strong>de</strong> los pob<strong>la</strong>dores <strong>en</strong> tanto espacio <strong>de</strong>participación y proyección social. Con <strong>el</strong>lo se espera <strong>de</strong>mostrar que <strong>la</strong> exist<strong>en</strong>cia<strong>de</strong> experi<strong>en</strong>cias educativas p<strong>en</strong>sadas <strong>de</strong>s<strong>de</strong> <strong>la</strong>s comunida<strong>de</strong>s y <strong>de</strong>sarrol<strong>la</strong>dassimultánea pero no coordinadam<strong>en</strong>te, da cu<strong>en</strong>ta <strong>de</strong> <strong>la</strong> c<strong>en</strong>tralidad <strong>de</strong> <strong>la</strong> educación<strong>en</strong> <strong>el</strong> proyecto histórico <strong>de</strong> los sectores popu<strong>la</strong>res.The objective of this pres<strong>en</strong>tation have re<strong>la</strong>tion with the political, social andcultural projections of a series of auto managed educative experi<strong>en</strong>ces for thepopu<strong>la</strong>r urban c<strong>la</strong>sses, betwe<strong>en</strong> 1957 and 1973 in Santiago of Chile, in the contextof the process of political mobilization that <strong>de</strong>v<strong>el</strong>oped in the governm<strong>en</strong>tof the Popu<strong>la</strong>r Unit. It will be analyzed three cases in which primary schoolswere constructed and administered by popu<strong>la</strong>r settlers, diverse forms of re<strong>la</strong>tionbeing g<strong>en</strong>erated betwe<strong>en</strong> community, school and State, crossed by thepolitical process in <strong>de</strong>v<strong>el</strong>opm<strong>en</strong>t.Across the memories of ex-pupils, proxies and teachers, there can be <strong>de</strong>monstratedthe educational experi<strong>en</strong>ces of the basic schools of the popu<strong>la</strong>tions LaVictoria of 1958, B<strong>la</strong>nqueado of 1968 and of the camp Nueva Habana of 1971,in or<strong>de</strong>r to analyze the cultural foundations of the educational proposal of thecommunity resi<strong>de</strong>nts as of participation and social projection. This is expectedto <strong>de</strong>monstrate that the exist<strong>en</strong>ce of educational experi<strong>en</strong>ces <strong>de</strong>signed and <strong>de</strong>v<strong>el</strong>opedby the communities simultaneously but not coordinat<strong>el</strong>y, accounts forthe importance of education in the historical project of the popu<strong>la</strong>r sectors.POTENGY, Gisélia F. y HOPPE, SigridI<strong>de</strong>alization of the past in a “total institution”Fundada <strong>en</strong> 1924 <strong>la</strong> Colonia Juliano Moreira (CJM) fue un macrohospital públicofe<strong>de</strong>ral para <strong>en</strong>fermos m<strong>en</strong>tales crónicos localizado <strong>en</strong> <strong>la</strong> zona oeste <strong>de</strong> Río <strong>de</strong>Janeiro. Seguía un mo<strong>de</strong>lo asist<strong>en</strong>cial <strong>de</strong> hospital-colonia que preconizaba <strong>la</strong>asist<strong>en</strong>cia hetero-familiar, recom<strong>en</strong>dando <strong>la</strong> aproximación <strong>en</strong>tre empleados ypaci<strong>en</strong>tes <strong>en</strong> <strong>la</strong> búsqueda <strong>de</strong> <strong>la</strong> integración social <strong>de</strong> éstos. La aplicación <strong>de</strong> estadirectriz obliga al Estado a proporcionar resi<strong>de</strong>ncia a los trabajadores. En estaépoca <strong>la</strong> Colonia podría <strong>de</strong>finirse como una institución total, según Goffman.Este período se concibe hoy como una época mítica <strong>en</strong> <strong>la</strong> que <strong>el</strong> Estado-patrónejercía un control total sobre <strong>la</strong> vida. Tras 1970 se asiste a un progresivo abandono<strong>de</strong> <strong>la</strong> CJM que <strong>de</strong>semboca <strong>en</strong> <strong>la</strong> inutilización <strong>de</strong> muchos <strong>de</strong> sus núcleos y<strong>en</strong> profundas interv<strong>en</strong>ciones <strong>en</strong> <strong>el</strong> área hospita<strong>la</strong>r, como <strong>la</strong> susp<strong>en</strong>sión <strong>de</strong> los<strong>el</strong>ectrochoques, <strong>la</strong> apertura <strong>de</strong> los cuartos <strong>de</strong> ais<strong>la</strong>mi<strong>en</strong>to y <strong>el</strong> cese <strong>de</strong> nuevasinternaciones. En 1996 se inician actuaciones administrativas con repercusiones<strong>en</strong> <strong>el</strong> sector <strong>de</strong> <strong>la</strong> salud, seguridad y vivi<strong>en</strong>da que nunca llegaron a implem<strong>en</strong>tarsepor causa <strong>de</strong> <strong>la</strong> inercia administrativa. <strong>Los</strong> resi<strong>de</strong>ntes pau<strong>la</strong>tinam<strong>en</strong>te se<strong>de</strong>s<strong>en</strong>ti<strong>en</strong><strong>de</strong>n <strong>de</strong> sus obligaciones ante <strong>el</strong> Estado y se liberan <strong>de</strong>l control socialejercido por <strong>la</strong> Administración <strong>de</strong>l Hosiptal.La situación muda <strong>en</strong> 2008 cuandoun conjunto <strong>de</strong> interv<strong>en</strong>ciones urbanísticas pret<strong>en</strong><strong>de</strong>n integrar <strong>el</strong> territorio <strong>de</strong> <strong>la</strong>Colonia al tejido urbano, transformándolo <strong>en</strong> barrio. El proyecto es acogido conreservas y durante <strong>el</strong> proceso los habitantes evocan un pasado i<strong>de</strong>alizado.MORRAS, Valeria y PAPPIER, VivianaFamilia, memoria e intercambio interg<strong>en</strong>eracional:Narrativas sobre <strong>en</strong>señanzas, apr<strong>en</strong>dizajes, experi<strong>en</strong>ciaseducativas, vida esco<strong>la</strong>rVoices, insights, memories, experi<strong>en</strong>ces, hopes are intertwined in the <strong>en</strong>countersbetwe<strong>en</strong> the differ<strong>en</strong>t g<strong>en</strong>erations that att<strong>en</strong><strong>de</strong>d a school which has retainedthe same name and “commitm<strong>en</strong>ts” for over a hundred years but whichhas also changed. This educational experi<strong>en</strong>ce that we want to share <strong>de</strong>altswith these <strong>en</strong>counters. It was ma<strong>de</strong> at “Joaquín V. González” Graduate School,<strong>de</strong>p<strong>en</strong><strong>de</strong>nt on the National University of La P<strong>la</strong>ta, with stu<strong>de</strong>nts from 6 th gra<strong>de</strong>in primary school. Bearing in mind that these stu<strong>de</strong>nts are close to graduating,we invited them to work on the history of such a familiar p<strong>la</strong>ce, though perhapsnot very w<strong>el</strong>l-known, and put forward “Our school th<strong>en</strong> and now” project.Our objectives were that, on the one hand, our stu<strong>de</strong>nts could get to know thediffer<strong>en</strong>ces and simi<strong>la</strong>rities betwe<strong>en</strong> their school in the past and their schoolnowadays, being able to i<strong>de</strong>ntify changes or not in attitu<strong>de</strong>s, concers, behaviourand interaction betwe<strong>en</strong> peers, with teachers and knowledge. On theother hand, we wanted stu<strong>de</strong>nts to recognize the value of differ<strong>en</strong>t g<strong>en</strong>erationsgetting closer and interacting with each other. In or<strong>de</strong>r to accomplish theseobjectives, they worked as reasearchers making questions and investigatingdiffer<strong>en</strong>t historical sources. They worked with objects b<strong>el</strong>onging to the schoolmuseum, vi<strong>de</strong>otapes, texts, photographs, and they carried out interviews. Theinterviews allow them to recover first-hand experi<strong>en</strong>ces from people that hadatt<strong>en</strong><strong>de</strong>d the school. In response to the stu<strong>de</strong>nts’ questions, the intervieweesrecalled their past. This transmission was ma<strong>de</strong> only through the experi<strong>en</strong>ce of<strong>oral</strong> history; making the testimony, the only historical source able to transmit it.The school has a past life, and the childr<strong>en</strong>, with their questions, h<strong>el</strong>ped historicizethis space which has be<strong>en</strong> lived in on a daily basis as a perman<strong>en</strong>t pres<strong>en</strong>t.The research was carried out throughout 2009, 2010 and 2011.Voces, miradas, recuerdos, experi<strong>en</strong>cias, ilusiones se <strong>en</strong>tre<strong>la</strong>zan <strong>en</strong> los <strong>en</strong>cu<strong>en</strong>tros<strong>en</strong>tre difer<strong>en</strong>tes g<strong>en</strong>eraciones que habitaron una escue<strong>la</strong> que durantemás <strong>de</strong> ci<strong>en</strong> años conserva <strong>el</strong> mismo nombre y sus “apuestas” pero quetambién ha cambiado. De estos <strong>en</strong>cu<strong>en</strong>tros trata <strong>la</strong> experi<strong>en</strong>cia educativa quet<strong>en</strong>emos para compartir, realizada <strong>en</strong> <strong>la</strong> Escue<strong>la</strong> Graduada “Joaquín V González”,<strong>de</strong>p<strong>en</strong>di<strong>en</strong>te <strong>de</strong> <strong>la</strong> Universidad Nacional <strong>de</strong> La P<strong>la</strong>ta 3 . Esta escue<strong>la</strong> <strong>en</strong> 6toaño <strong>de</strong> <strong>la</strong> primaria propone para sus alumnos <strong>en</strong> forma optativa y a contraturnoun espacio <strong>de</strong> activida<strong>de</strong>s l<strong>la</strong>mado “Jornada Ext<strong>en</strong>dida” <strong>en</strong> <strong>el</strong> cual se trabajandifer<strong>en</strong>tes temáticas, vincu<strong>la</strong>das a difer<strong>en</strong>tes espacios curricu<strong>la</strong>res y losapr<strong>en</strong>dizajes <strong>de</strong> los alumnos no se evalúan <strong>de</strong> un modo tradicional.La experi<strong>en</strong>cia que contaremos se realizó <strong>en</strong> <strong>el</strong> espacio curricu<strong>la</strong>r l<strong>la</strong>madoLaboratorio <strong>de</strong> Ci<strong>en</strong>cias Sociales, <strong>en</strong> <strong>el</strong> que se concibe al apr<strong>en</strong>dizaje <strong>de</strong> <strong>la</strong>sCi<strong>en</strong>cias Sociales como un proceso activo. En ese espacio se pret<strong>en</strong><strong>de</strong> trabajar<strong>la</strong> realidad social <strong>de</strong>s<strong>de</strong> situaciones problemáticas que result<strong>en</strong> significativasy motivadoras para los intereses <strong>de</strong>l grupo y cuya resolución implique que losalumnos cuestion<strong>en</strong> lo obvio. La modalidad <strong>de</strong> trabajo es <strong>de</strong> taller don<strong>de</strong> sepromueva <strong>el</strong> diálogo y <strong>la</strong> discusión fundam<strong>en</strong>tada y respetuosa.T<strong>en</strong>i<strong>en</strong>do <strong>en</strong> cu<strong>en</strong>ta que <strong>el</strong> grupo <strong>de</strong> alumnos <strong>de</strong> 11 y 12 años estaba próximo a<strong>de</strong>spedirse <strong>de</strong> <strong>la</strong> escue<strong>la</strong> con su correspondi<strong>en</strong>te viaje <strong>de</strong> egresados 4 propusimostrabajar con <strong>la</strong> <strong>historia</strong> <strong>de</strong> ese lugar tan cotidiano pero tal vez poco conocidoy propusimos <strong>el</strong> proyecto “Nuestra escue<strong>la</strong> ayer y hoy”. A través <strong>de</strong>l mismonos p<strong>la</strong>nteamos como objetivos que nuestros alumnos pudieran por un <strong>la</strong>doconocer difer<strong>en</strong>cias y similitu<strong>de</strong>s <strong>en</strong> <strong>la</strong> vida cotidiana <strong>de</strong> <strong>la</strong> escue<strong>la</strong> <strong>de</strong> ayer y<strong>la</strong> <strong>de</strong> hoy, i<strong>de</strong>ntificando cambios y perman<strong>en</strong>cias <strong>en</strong> actitu<strong>de</strong>s, inquietu<strong>de</strong>s,modos <strong>de</strong> actuar y re<strong>la</strong>cionarse <strong>en</strong>tre pares, con los doc<strong>en</strong>tes y con <strong>el</strong> conocimi<strong>en</strong>to.Por otro, que consi<strong>de</strong>raran valioso <strong>el</strong> acercami<strong>en</strong>to y <strong>el</strong> diálogo <strong>en</strong>tredistintas g<strong>en</strong>eraciones. Y por último, que valoraran <strong>la</strong> escue<strong>la</strong> como <strong>el</strong> lugardon<strong>de</strong> vivieron una parte fundam<strong>en</strong>tal <strong>de</strong> sus vidas.La propuesta <strong>de</strong> trabajo se vi<strong>en</strong>e implem<strong>en</strong>tando <strong>de</strong>s<strong>de</strong> <strong>el</strong> año 2009 y finalizacon una exposición compartida con los padres <strong>de</strong> los alumnos don<strong>de</strong>, a través<strong>de</strong> una muestra <strong>de</strong> fotografías y <strong>de</strong> trabajos, los chicos muestran y narran loapr<strong>en</strong>dido a lo <strong>la</strong>rgo <strong>de</strong>l proyecto.SCHOEPF, Christe<strong>en</strong>What more can I t<strong>el</strong>l you? Object Biography and OralHistory as companion methodologies in historical investigation.Object biography is a methodology that explores the notion that objects canbe consi<strong>de</strong>red to have a life or series of lives that can be examined and explored71

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!