28.01.2015 Views

Chaosophy - autonomous learning

Chaosophy - autonomous learning

Chaosophy - autonomous learning

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

Our two authors have tried, and it's their attempt that we are<br />

discussing here.<br />

I simply said, and will say again, that the proper approach to the<br />

problem seems to me to go through an extremely specific pass: the<br />

place of the object, the function of the drive in a social formation.<br />

Just a remark in regard to the "it works" which is put forward<br />

as an argument in favor of the pertinence of the machine, or the<br />

book in question. Of course it works. And I was going to say that<br />

for me, too, in a certain sense, it works. One may note that any<br />

theoretically invested practice initially has a good chance of working.<br />

This is not a criterion in itself.<br />

Roger Dadoun: The main problem that your book raises IS no<br />

doubt this: how will it work politically, since you acknowledge the<br />

political as a principal "machination." Witness the scope or the<br />

meticulousness with which you dealt with the "socius" and, notably,<br />

its ethnographic, anthropological aspects.<br />

Pierre Clastres: Deleuze and Guattari, the former a philosopher,<br />

the latter a psychoanalyst, are reflecting together on capitalism. In<br />

order to conceive capitalism, they go through schizophrenia, in<br />

which they see the effects and limits of our society. And in order to<br />

conceive schizophrenia, they go through Oedipal psychoanalysis,<br />

but like Attila: in their wal{e, nothing much is left standing.<br />

Between the two, between the description of familialism (the Oedipal<br />

triangle) and the project of schizoanalysis, there is the biggest<br />

chapter in Anti-Oedipus, the third, "Savages, Barbarians, Civilized<br />

Men." This essentially concerns societies that are usually the<br />

ethnologists' object of study. What is ethnology doing here<br />

It ensures the consistency of Deleuze and Guattari's undertalcing,<br />

which is very strong, by shoring up their argument with non-Western<br />

examples (an examination of primitive societies and barbaric<br />

84 /

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!