02.04.2013 Views

Odger's English Common Law

Odger's English Common Law

Odger's English Common Law

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

CRIME AND TORT. 45<br />

should claim damages from him ; each plaintiff must show a separate<br />

loss peculiar to himself. Thus, a conspiracy by two or more persons to do<br />

an unlawful act is in itself a crime. In order to sustain an action for such<br />

a conspiracy the plaintiff must not only prove the conspiracy ; he must<br />

also show that some wrongful act was done in pursuance of it by the<br />

defendants which has caused some special or particular damage to himself. 1<br />

It is always, however, a defence to a charge of crime that<br />

the mind of the accused did not go with his act. He must<br />

know what he is doing, and he must know that what he is<br />

doing is wrong. He must possess both will and judgment<br />

and be free to exercise both. Hence no man can commit<br />

a crime when he is asleep or has been thoroughly drugged ;<br />

but drunkenness voluntarily produced is no defence in ordi-<br />

nary cases. No infant under seven years of age can-commit a<br />

crime. Coercion and extreme necessity are defences in all<br />

save the gravest cases. A lunatic will be punished if he<br />

knows both what he is doing and that he ought not to do it,<br />

although his desire to do it may be prompted by some<br />

delusion. But he will not be liable where the delusion is<br />

of such a kind that, if the facts were as he supposed, his act<br />

would be justifiable. So, if a criminal act be committed<br />

under a reasonable mistake as to a matter of fact, the<br />

prisoner's guilt depends on whether he would still be liable<br />

if the facts were as he supposed. A mistake as to the law<br />

excuses no one.<br />

In ordinary cases the burden of proving such facts as som-<br />

nambulism, lunacy, duress and mistake lies on the prisoner.<br />

For the law presumes that every one of full age knows what<br />

he is doing, knows right from wrong, and knows (and there-<br />

fore intends) the natural consequences of his act.<br />

1 See post, pp. 625 et seg.

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!