SLC Thesis Template - ResearchSpace@Auckland - The University ...
SLC Thesis Template - ResearchSpace@Auckland - The University ...
SLC Thesis Template - ResearchSpace@Auckland - The University ...
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
Whether Rome or Carthage should give laws to the nations they would<br />
know the next day before nightfall. For not Africa, they said, or Italy,<br />
but the whole world would be the reward of victory. A reward<br />
matched by the danger for those whom the fortune of battle should not<br />
favour.<br />
Moore, 1955, 485<br />
Where Polybius represents Scipio claiming that the Romans were fighting for world<br />
domination, Livy places it in Hannibal’s harangue to the Carthaginian component in his<br />
army, telling them that they faced either servitude or ruling the world (Livy, 30.33.8-<br />
12). Silius Italicus follows Livy‟s preference for Hannibal to voice the opinion that the<br />
battle was for world domination, and similarly places it toward close of Hannibal‟s<br />
harangue:<br />
Non altera restat<br />
iam Libyae nec Dardaniis pugna altera restat.<br />
certatus nobis hodie dominum accipit orbis.<br />
174<br />
Pun. 17.335-7<br />
„Neither Carthage nor Rome can fight another battle. Today must<br />
decide the struggle between us for mastery of the world.‟<br />
Duff, 1989, 463.<br />
In the Punica the ascendancy 373 of Scipio has been read as the first step toward the<br />
principate and the one-man rule of imperial Rome. Of all the various representations in<br />
the ancient texts over what Rome and Carthage were fighting for at Zama, it is perhaps<br />
the Hadrianic author, Florus, who summarises the outcome in terms that most closely<br />
reflect the historical reality: Africa was the prize of victory, the rest of the world soon<br />
followed: praemiumque victoriae Africa fuit et secutus Africam statim terrarium orbis<br />
(Florus, 1.22.61).<br />
Polybius lauds Hannibal and Zama with proverbs and quotes from Homeric poetry,<br />
closing the episode with the highest praise of Scipio. Zama is the only event given such<br />
treatment in the extant sections of the Histories which reflects Polybius‟ belief in the<br />
pivotal role its outcome played for changing the balance of power across the ancient<br />
Mediterranean world. Polybius‟ first quotation, described by Walbank 374 as a<br />
contaminated mixture of Homer‟s Iliad 2.804; 4.437 and Odyssey 19.175, compares the<br />
373 Fears, 1981, 779: the literary image of Scipio assumes various attributes of Hellenistic kingship.<br />
Ennius celebrated Scipio as invictus and thus associated the victory with the person not Rome as a society.<br />
Marks, 2005, argues for Silius Italicus presenting Scipio as a „good king‟ and virtuous princeps ideal for<br />
Domitian but is not entirely convimcing.<br />
374 Walbank, 1967, 459.