SLC Thesis Template - ResearchSpace@Auckland - The University ...
SLC Thesis Template - ResearchSpace@Auckland - The University ...
SLC Thesis Template - ResearchSpace@Auckland - The University ...
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
Chapter 7: <strong>The</strong> Legacy ‘War’<br />
This chapter is divided into four parts as it examines the treatments of Hannibal<br />
following his defeat at Zama and his metamorphosis to an eternal enemy of Rome. <strong>The</strong><br />
first section covers the immediate aftermath of the battle at Zama when authors faced<br />
the choice of depicting Hannibal accepting the defeat as final or choosing to continue<br />
warfare, and both representations are extant.<br />
For those texts that depict Hannibal as a sworn enemy of Rome, presenting him not<br />
accepting the defeat as final is easily compatible with the author‟s overall presentation<br />
(e.g. Cornelius Nepos, Hannibal, 7.3; Seneca, NQ 3, praef. 5-7; Silius Italicus, Pun.<br />
17.611-2). <strong>The</strong> portrait becomes more complex in those texts that depict Hannibal as a<br />
sworn enemy and accepting the defeat as final, especially if he is also presented actively<br />
persuading the Carthaginians either to sue for peace or to accept Scipio‟s terms (e.g.<br />
Polybius, Hist. 15.19.2-9; Livy, 30.35.11). On the face of it, a „sworn enemy‟ of Rome<br />
seems an unlikely figure to sue for peace. If, on the other hand, Hannibal dissembled his<br />
attitude toward Rome in order to save both citizens and the physical city of Carthage<br />
from the consequences of slavery, plundering and burning at the hands of Scipio‟s army,<br />
the representation may be interpreted as displaying Punic trickery.<br />
From the Carthaginian point of view, Hannibal might even be considered a saviour of<br />
their city. <strong>The</strong> first section explores this slightly incongruous (for Roman texts) portrait<br />
of Hannibal because such a depiction adds to the aura of his reputation as an<br />
extraordinary figure, and, although it may not be considered a particularly strong or<br />
„iconic‟ representation of Hannibal today, it has an intrinsic value as an alternative,<br />
positive portrait of Hannibal that probably has non-Roman origins. It is also important<br />
because it reappears in a slightly different guise in Livy‟s fourth decad a few years after<br />
Zama when Hannibal again saves Carthage from Roman punishment. He solved an<br />
economic crisis that enabled the Carthaginians to continue paying the indemnity due to<br />
Rome, although the traditions differ on Hannibal‟s methodology.<br />
In the second section of this chapter it will be argued that Livy‟s depiction of<br />
Hannibal as a controversial politician develops into the next portrait of Hannibal: <strong>The</strong><br />
scapegoat and warmonger. Hannibal became the focus for Roman anger and had to<br />
escape from Carthage. <strong>The</strong> devolution of blame onto one man has advantages for the<br />
185