SLC Thesis Template - ResearchSpace@Auckland - The University ...
SLC Thesis Template - ResearchSpace@Auckland - The University ...
SLC Thesis Template - ResearchSpace@Auckland - The University ...
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
Adesse finem belli ac laboris, in manibus esse praedam Carthaginis,<br />
reditum domum in patriam ad parentes, liberos, coniuges penatesque<br />
deos. Celsus haec corpore voltuque ita laeto ut vicisse iam crederes<br />
dicebat.<br />
Livy, 30.32.10-11<br />
<strong>The</strong> end of the war and hardship was at hand, the spoils of Carthage<br />
within reach, and the return home to their native city, to parents,<br />
children, wives and household gods. So erect did he stand as he spoke<br />
these words and with so happy a look on his face that one would have<br />
believed him already the victor.<br />
Moore, 1955, 489<br />
Silius Italicus treats the material differently. If dispositions of the two armies were<br />
included in the Punica then they must have been placed before the harangues, in an<br />
AABc(Br) pattern. Scipio‟s harangue is bracketed because he is cut short before saying<br />
anything; his men are so eager to fight they don‟t require further encouragement (Pun.<br />
17.340). Thus only Hannibal actually addresses his troops and his harangue is longer<br />
than the one in Livy‟s text. <strong>The</strong> emphasised tu or te throughout the speech shows that<br />
Hannibal recognises individual soldiers more quickly by their feats in battle than by<br />
their names. He recognises the arms that attacked and killed, or attacked and wounded<br />
many famous Romans (Flaminius, Paulus, Marcellus, Gracchus, Appius, Fulvius,<br />
Crispinus and the elder Scipio are all mentioned, Pun. 17.295-337). Hannibal concludes<br />
with an acknowledgment that this battle is „final‟ and echoes the ahistorical claim that it<br />
is for world domination:<br />
Battle at Zama<br />
„certatus nobis hodie dominum accipit orbis.‟<br />
Pun. 17.337<br />
„Today must decide the struggle between us for mastery of the world.‟<br />
Duff, 1989, 463.<br />
In Polybius‟ description of the battle at Zama, everything that could go wrong for<br />
Hannibal did go wrong. <strong>The</strong> elephants began their charge but panicked. Some ran back<br />
toward Hannibal‟s ranks, others ran down the spaces created as Scipio‟s men stepped<br />
aside. <strong>The</strong> Roman infantry marched forward and charged, gradually gaining ground. As<br />
the Carthaginian mercenaries began to give way, some turned and began to attack the<br />
Carthaginians behind them, who fought back. Hannibal would not allow those who<br />
turned back into the ranks; his men kept their spears lowered. <strong>The</strong> Roman cavalry<br />
defeated and chased off the Carthaginian cavalry. <strong>The</strong> battle hung in the balance until<br />
182