SLC Thesis Template - ResearchSpace@Auckland - The University ...
SLC Thesis Template - ResearchSpace@Auckland - The University ...
SLC Thesis Template - ResearchSpace@Auckland - The University ...
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
prevent the Romans from recruiting men within Italy. His advice continued to be that<br />
Antiochus should invade Italy and plan on using Italian supplies and recruits (Livy,<br />
34.60.2). Cornelius Nepos remarks that if Antiochus had followed Hannibal‟s advice the<br />
battle for power in the Mediterranean may well have been fought nearer the Tiber than<br />
<strong>The</strong>rmopylae (Cornelius Nepos, Hann. 8.3).<br />
Livy‟s unfolding narrative shows how Hannibal‟s advice was not followed. By the<br />
time that Hannibal convinced Antiochus to adopt his strategy it was too late, the<br />
necessary support from Carthage has dissipated (if it had even existed). Three years is a<br />
long time in politics, ancient and modern. When Hannibal‟s agent, Aristo, contacts the<br />
Carthaginians on his behalf, they report the matter to Rome; Aristo himself manages to<br />
escape (Livy, 34.61.1; cf. Justinian, 31.4.1; Appian, Syriaca, 7.29). Whether or not the<br />
convoluted story has any historical foundation, 426 it specifically associates Hannibal<br />
with the suggestion of an invasion of Italy, with all the memories that invokes for Livy‟s<br />
readership. It is an association that Livy repeats again, two books later.<br />
Livy gives Hannibal a substantial speech in which he supports the Acarnanian<br />
general, Alexander, urging Antiochus to make a treaty with Philip of Macedon, and not<br />
to rely on the Boeotians and <strong>The</strong>ssalians for support. Hannibal‟s view of the overall<br />
strategy is unchanged, repeating his earlier argument that Antiochus should invade Italy,<br />
with the added note that nothing would frighten the Romans more than the thought that<br />
Hannibal was in Italy: et, qui maximus iis terror est, Hannibalem in Italia esse audirent<br />
(Livy, 36.7). Hannibal‟s point about the psychological effect on Rome of invading Italy<br />
is good but, once again, his advice is not taken (Livy, 36.8.1). 427<br />
<strong>The</strong> next time Livy depicts Hannibal advising Antiochus the circumstances have<br />
changed. Antiochus had been defeated by the Romans 428 and was back in Ephesus.<br />
Hannibal is presented as the only one of the king‟s advisors warning him to prepare for<br />
a Roman invasion of Asia. Indeed, Hannibal declares that he was more surprised that the<br />
Roman legions had not landed yet:<br />
426 It is questionable whether Greek generals would seriously urge warfare in their own lands in<br />
preference to drawing the Roman legions out to fight elsewhere.<br />
427 Philip had been defeated; his son, Demetrius, was held hostage at Rome. Eventually Philip is rewarded<br />
for his loyalty with his son‟s release and a promised refund on the indemnity (Hist. 21.1). <strong>The</strong> political<br />
divisions in Greece, as predicted by Hannibal, divert Antiochus‟ attention from the main goal, Rome.<br />
<strong>The</strong>re is another distraction that signals defeat for Antiochus: his new marriage (Hist. 20.8; Livy, 36.15).<br />
428 Antiochus had two significant defeats, at <strong>The</strong>rmopylae, 191, and Magnesia, 190. For discussion of the<br />
history, see Errington, 1989, CAH 8, 272-82.<br />
201