SLC Thesis Template - ResearchSpace@Auckland - The University ...
SLC Thesis Template - ResearchSpace@Auckland - The University ...
SLC Thesis Template - ResearchSpace@Auckland - The University ...
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
does Scipio. Appian closes the scene when Hannibal‟s men are defeated and Hannibal<br />
decides to escape (Appian, Pun. 8.7.47).<br />
Silius Italicus‟ representation of Zama is different again. If there was an elephant<br />
charge, it is not in the Punica, but there may be a poetic allusion to the pathways created<br />
by the Romans stepping aside to allow the elephants to pass when Silius says that wide<br />
passages appeared as men fell which others rush to fill (Pun. 17.420-5). Silius Italicus<br />
placed Macedonian horsemen fighting for Hannibal as well as Greek infantry in their<br />
traditional phalanx whereas Livy only mentions Macedonian infantry in the second line<br />
behind the Carthaginians: in secunda acie Carthaginienses Afrosque et Macedonum<br />
legionem (Livy, 30.33.4; cf. Pun. 17.413-9). <strong>The</strong> epic Scipio searches out Hannibal for<br />
single combat: illum igitur lustrans circumfert lumina campo rimaturque ducem (Pun.<br />
17.517-8). For the last time, Juno intervened and removed Hannibal from the field of<br />
battle in order to protect him. She is invisible to the Carthaginians who believe that<br />
Hannibal has deserted them, consequently they lose heart: ingruit Ausonius versosque<br />
agit aequore toto rector (Pun. 17.585).<br />
Florus summarised Zama as an evenhanded battle at which the two sides fought long<br />
and hard. He says that everyone agreed that both armies made the best of the occasion,<br />
Scipio said as much about Hannibal and Hannibal about Scipio: hoc Scipio de Annibalis,<br />
Annibal de Scipionis exercitu praedicaverunt (Florus, 1.22.60).<br />
At Scipio‟s triumph 401 the greatest attraction for the crowds, and the final image of<br />
Hannibal in the Punica, is a painting that depicts Hannibal running away: sed non ulla<br />
magis mentesque oculosque tenebat quam visa Hannibalis campis fugientis imago (Pun.<br />
17.643-4). Of course, a painting 402 is no substitute for parading Hannibal in person and<br />
the dying Syphax made a poor second choice. 403<br />
401 Livy 38, 52-3 casts a retrospective cloud over Scipio Africanus‟ triumph in Scipio‟s trial some years<br />
later. See Beard, 2007, 253. Some suggest that Scipio „allowed‟ Hannibal his freedom, De Beer, 1969,<br />
290; Lancel 1998, 180, and that Scipio had the foresight to recognise that Hannibal as the most capable<br />
person to aid Carthaginian recovery.<br />
402 Appian, 8.66, lists categories of items in Scipio‟s triumph, including paintings depicting events from<br />
the war; he does not name any of the prisoners.<br />
403 Silius Italicus favours the tradition that is today extant in Polybius but not in Livy when describing the<br />
dying Syphax being carried through Scipio‟s triumphal procession on a litter (Pun. 17.629-30). Livy says<br />
that Syphax died in prison beforehand thus denying Scipio the satisfaction of displaying either Hannibal<br />
or Syphax (Livy, 30.45.4-5). Polybius said that Syphax died soon after the triumph (Hist. 16.23). See<br />
Beard, 2007, 129-132 for an argument that the supposed ancestral custom to kill kings or foreign leaders<br />
paraded in triumphal processions is a myth based on very little evidence. Beard notes that most captives<br />
executed in one text are found to have remained alive in another text. Syphax is another example with<br />
opposing traditions but no-one claims that he was killed as part of the triumphal celebration.<br />
184