30.04.2015 Views

Probate & Trust Law Section Conference Manual ... - Minnesota CLE

Probate & Trust Law Section Conference Manual ... - Minnesota CLE

Probate & Trust Law Section Conference Manual ... - Minnesota CLE

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

ultimate burning out of the sun and destruction of our solar system. It<br />

is way better than Pepsi.” Any direction to hold a single asset as a<br />

pure investment under any and all conditions is as foolish as our<br />

hypothetical clause suggests, and both drafters and trustees should<br />

avoid such an obvious trap.<br />

Alternatively, specifying a future state can lead to little real help for<br />

the fiduciary: “My trustee shall continue to hold the contributed<br />

common shares in Coca Cola as an asset of the trust but may sell<br />

such shares as they, in their absolute discretion, shall deem prudent<br />

based upon the trustee’s evaluation of market conditions, consumer<br />

tastes and preference and other relevant macroeconomic factors.”<br />

Unfortunately, “may sell” is as good as “shall sell.” Even if a trustee<br />

sought to hold the asset, the expense of evaluating and documenting<br />

their evaluation of market conditions, etc., may render trust<br />

administration uneconomical.<br />

B. Statement of Governance Method and Oversight?<br />

b. Cost Savings?<br />

If a long-term trust relaxes the basic obligation to diversify, can a<br />

trustee obtain comfort from a clear statement of governance<br />

obligations on the part of the trustee? This will often be an uncertain<br />

undertaking and requires early and detailed work with the proposed<br />

trustee to determine what level of detail will provide sufficient<br />

comfort to the trustee while meeting the needs of the grantor.<br />

A direction to retain may actually result in greater expense of administration<br />

that ordinary trust administration if the trustee is obligated to evaluate<br />

multiple factors in making the decision to sell or retain. This will typically<br />

not square with the expectations of many grantors.<br />

c. Sample Clause: Family Business<br />

Provision<br />

UPIA Reference<br />

The Grantor hereby specifically exercises all<br />

rights that he may have to limit, restrict or<br />

eliminate <strong>Trust</strong>ee duties under <strong>Minnesota</strong><br />

Statutes §510B.15, the Uniform Prudent<br />

Investor Act, by severely limiting the duty to<br />

diversify the assets of the <strong>Trust</strong> in light of the<br />

special circumstances of this <strong>Trust</strong>.<br />

Diversification is not a significant purpose of<br />

this <strong>Trust</strong>. The <strong>Trust</strong> will initially hold a<br />

majority stake in the XYZ company, a family<br />

business, and it is my firm intention that the<br />

<strong>Trust</strong>ee shall continue to hold its interest in<br />

XYZ, including any successor entity or<br />

organization, during the <strong>Trust</strong> term unless the<br />

Calls forth the source of<br />

authority (§1(b)) and<br />

states the intent is to<br />

limiting a UPIA<br />

provision<br />

Indicates purpose of trust.<br />

As trust term increases,<br />

purpose elaboration<br />

increases as does the<br />

elaboration of how the<br />

purpose aligns with the<br />

§2(b) factors.<br />

28

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!