24.12.2014 Views

Earthquake Engineering Research - HKU Libraries - The University ...

Earthquake Engineering Research - HKU Libraries - The University ...

Earthquake Engineering Research - HKU Libraries - The University ...

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

229<br />

14% to 45% (under El Centre earthquake), 11% ~ 24% (under Mexico City earthquake), and 10% ~<br />

57% (under Gebze earthquake) compared to the passive control system. <strong>The</strong> structural responses with<br />

the hybrid control system under El Centro earthquake are decreased by 1% - 26% compared to the<br />

active control system. All the structural responses except the peak shear at deck level (J 2 ) are<br />

decreased by 0.3% - 35% under Mexico City earthquake. J 2 is increased by 2%. In the case of<br />

Gebze earthquake, the structural responses are decreased by 4% - 24%, whereas the normed moment<br />

at deck level (Jio) is increased by 2%. Moreover, active and hybrid control systems are satisfied the<br />

actuator requirement (Le., Max force: 1000 kN, Max Stroke: 0.2 m, Max velocity: 1 m/s) given by<br />

Dyke et al (2000).<br />

(a) El Centro earthquake (b) Mexico City earthquake (c) Gebze earthquake<br />

FIGURE 2 RESTORING FORCE OF LRB AT PIER 2<br />

TABLE 2<br />

MAXIMUM EVALUATION CRITERIA FOR ALL THE THREE EARTHQUAKES<br />

Criterion<br />

J r peak base shear<br />

J 2- peak shear at deck level<br />

J 3- peak overturning mom<br />

J 4- peak mom. at deck level<br />

J 5- peak dev. of cable tension<br />

JCT peak deck displacement<br />

J 7- normed base shear<br />

Jg- normed shear at deck level<br />

Jg- normed overturning mom.<br />

JUT normed mom. at deck level<br />

IIP normed dev. of cable tension<br />

J 12- peak control force<br />

J 13- peak stroke<br />

JV peak power<br />

J 15- peak total power<br />

lie- no. of control devices<br />

Ji7- no. of sensors<br />

Jis~ no. of resources<br />

Dvke et aL<br />

0.4582<br />

1.3784<br />

0.5836<br />

1.2246<br />

0.1861<br />

3.5640<br />

0.3983<br />

1.4271<br />

0.4552<br />

1.4569<br />

2.2968e-2<br />

1.7145e-3<br />

1.9540<br />

7.3689e-3<br />

6.9492e-4<br />

24<br />

9<br />

30<br />

Passive Control<br />

0.5459<br />

1.4616<br />

0.6188<br />

1.2656<br />

0.2077<br />

3.8289<br />

0.4211<br />

1.5502<br />

0.4815<br />

1.4429<br />

2.2327e-2<br />

2.l611e-3<br />

2.0993<br />

-<br />

-<br />

24<br />

,<br />

-<br />

Active Control<br />

0.5071<br />

1.1576<br />

0.4485<br />

0.8792<br />

0.1474<br />

1.8023<br />

0.3755<br />

0.9510<br />

0.3563<br />

0.7618<br />

1.6176e-2<br />

1.9608e-3<br />

0.9886<br />

9.3311e-3<br />

8.7997e-4<br />

24<br />

9<br />

30<br />

Hybrid Control<br />

0.4854<br />

0.9360<br />

0.4471<br />

0.6719<br />

0.1462<br />

1.6629<br />

0.3723<br />

0.9169<br />

0.3336<br />

0.7799<br />

1.8215e-2<br />

LRB+HA:<br />

2.6438e-3<br />

LRB: 1.2246e-3<br />

HA: 1.9608e-3<br />

0.9118<br />

6.6678e-3<br />

8.4888e-4<br />

LRB-fHA:<br />

24-^-24<br />

9<br />

30

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!