take consistent ethical actions aga<strong>in</strong>st any genocide.The responsibility of <strong>in</strong>dividuals also <strong>in</strong>cludes tak<strong>in</strong>ga stand aga<strong>in</strong>st human rights violations and dehumanizationof any people, and hav<strong>in</strong>g'the courage to refuseto follow any orders, even when one serves <strong>in</strong> amilitary organization, that call for the murders of<strong>in</strong>nocent people. It also means refus<strong>in</strong>g to acceptassignments to plan such actions for the future. Someyears ago, a graduate of one of America's greatmilitary academies was ordered to prepare plans forpreemptive strikes aga<strong>in</strong>st the cities of the Soviet Unionand refused; he was ordered to quarters, courtmartialled,and then given a dishonorable discharge from themilitary. In the context of the fears America held ofSoviet nuclear attacks, it was ostensibly legitimate forthe United States military to be plann<strong>in</strong>g scenarios ofdefense aga<strong>in</strong>st a possible enemy, but this youngmilitary officer knew that the plann<strong>in</strong>g of self-defensecannot <strong>in</strong>clude preparations for murder<strong>in</strong>g hundredsof thousands and millions of civilians. He was preparedto pay a price for stand<strong>in</strong>g up for what he knew to bea true pr<strong>in</strong>ciple of American democracy, the universalpr<strong>in</strong>ciple of respect for human life.The Courage to WithstandOne's Own NationThere is no easy way for an <strong>in</strong>dividual to makean endur<strong>in</strong>g commitment aga<strong>in</strong>st genocide. For whenthe time comes, if we are citizens of a state that iscommitt<strong>in</strong>g genocide, it means that we must have thecourage to stand up aga<strong>in</strong>st our own nation, society,perhaps even our own families.This was the choice Germans had to make dur<strong>in</strong>gWorld War II, whether to follow the orders to committhe murders that Hitler and his staff demanded of themor to defy those orders and attempt to circumvent theirown government. Interest<strong>in</strong>gly enough, <strong>in</strong> recent yearsa study has been reported of some hundred Germanswho did refuse to follow orders, and to everyone' ssurprise it has turned out that ' the majority were notmade to pay for their refusal. But of course it is notalways possible to count on this. On the contrary, thechoice of stand<strong>in</strong>g for pr<strong>in</strong>ciple has to <strong>in</strong>clude th<strong>in</strong>k<strong>in</strong>gabout whether or not one would be prepared to makethe ultimate sacrifice of oneself rather than participate<strong>in</strong> kill<strong>in</strong>g <strong>in</strong>nocent others. All the <strong>in</strong>formation we havefrom public op<strong>in</strong>ion studies and social science studiessuggests that the majority of Americans, and themajority of all human be<strong>in</strong>gs <strong>in</strong> this world, would dowhat they were told if they were commandedby theirsuperior officers <strong>in</strong> the military, or their governmentofficials, to go and kill masses of helpless men,women, and children of another people." I want thisessay to raise the que'stion for you the reader whetheryou are the k<strong>in</strong>d of person who is willi ng to be diferent<strong>in</strong> pr<strong>in</strong>ciple. The chart on page 154 <strong>in</strong>dicates what awill<strong>in</strong>gness to be different entails.Proposal for a World <strong>Genocide</strong> Early Warn<strong>in</strong>gSystem Foundation'The concept of a <strong>Genocide</strong> Early Warn<strong>in</strong>g Systemhas been published <strong>in</strong> a variety of articles and chapters,and has earned strong positive reviews from humanrights specialists, social scientists, and some nationalleaders. Willie Brandt, former Chancellor of WestGermany, wrote, "Your plan to develop concepts andproposals for dissem<strong>in</strong>at<strong>in</strong>g the <strong>in</strong>formation on thegenocide and human rights data bank sounds fasc<strong>in</strong>at<strong>in</strong>g.I would like to assure you that I am ready to givemy moral support. " A former U. S. Deputy AssistantSecretary of State for Human Rights, Roberta Cohen,says, "Your proposal to establish a <strong>Genocide</strong> EarlyWarn<strong>in</strong>g System is an excellent idea. Had such asystem operated effectively <strong>in</strong> the past, countless livesmight have been saved <strong>in</strong> many parts of the world. "The purpose of the <strong>Genocide</strong> Early Warn<strong>in</strong>gon three levels. FirstSystem is to collect <strong>in</strong>formationand foremost, it is to assemble <strong>in</strong>formation of ongo<strong>in</strong>ggenocides and massacres <strong>in</strong> the world on a regular,authoritative basis. Second, it is to ma<strong>in</strong>ta<strong>in</strong> a cont<strong>in</strong>uousmonitor<strong>in</strong>g of <strong>in</strong>formation on human rights violations.Third, it is to be the basis for a series of researchesto understand more of the patterns throughwhich massacre, mass murder, and genocide build up<strong>in</strong> a society, so that we will learn how to predict andalert people to the <strong>in</strong>creas<strong>in</strong>g dangers of mass murders<strong>in</strong> different societies well before they happen.1here is no data bank for human rights <strong>in</strong>formation<strong>in</strong> the world today. Moreover, there is no responsi-ble ongo<strong>in</strong>g <strong>in</strong>formation source for the news of severeconditions of massacre and mass murder. What happenscharacteristically is that the <strong>in</strong>formation is reportedepisodically <strong>in</strong> certa<strong>in</strong> newspapers. At the time of thesereports they are often, characteristically, described as"unconfirmed" or "alleged. " In any case, hav<strong>in</strong>g pr<strong>in</strong>tedthe news, these newspapers tend not to follow up withmany subsequent stories because, after all, the storyhas already been pr<strong>in</strong>ted! In other words, from thepo<strong>in</strong>t of view of the news that "makes news, " once amassacre has been reported, even its cont<strong>in</strong>uation maynot be that "<strong>in</strong>terest<strong>in</strong>g" to those news sources that seethemselves as hav<strong>in</strong>g to provide a k<strong>in</strong>d of enterta<strong>in</strong>mentquality with "new" stories for their readers.The problem goes deeper, however. Even if thenews track<strong>in</strong>g is more complete — as happens whensome country or area of the world seizes the imag<strong>in</strong>ationof the rest of the world — the reader still is left withan experience of learn<strong>in</strong>g that someth<strong>in</strong>g terrible hashappened that he or she can do noth<strong>in</strong>g about. Such152 GENOCIDE
experiences often produce feel<strong>in</strong>gs of despair orcynicism or both for readers.The purpose of creat<strong>in</strong>g a <strong>Genocide</strong> Early Warn<strong>in</strong>gSystem Foundation is to help to develop a center thatnot only will receive, house, and make available ona cont<strong>in</strong>uous basis <strong>in</strong>formation of ongo<strong>in</strong>g massacres<strong>in</strong> the world, but also that will be an <strong>in</strong>ternationalagency on behalf of human society as it speaks for the<strong>in</strong>tention of humank<strong>in</strong>d to care about and protect humanlife. The <strong>in</strong>formations to be delivered to society by theearly warn<strong>in</strong>g system are not only to ma<strong>in</strong>ta<strong>in</strong> updatedfactual <strong>in</strong>formation, but also to convey the presenceof an <strong>in</strong>ternationalagency that represents the evolutionof a humane society which <strong>in</strong>tends to keep a spotlighton the wrongdo<strong>in</strong>gs of mass murder. Sadly, themillions of words written about genocides to daterepresent essentially cry<strong>in</strong>g after th'e task is over. Thereal purpose of early warn<strong>in</strong>gs of genocide is to helpthe world develop new energies and new forms forattack<strong>in</strong>g mass murder long before the murderers havecompleted their horrible task.The <strong>Genocide</strong> Early Warn<strong>in</strong>g System we haveplanned is built on a conceptual structure that assembles<strong>in</strong>formation over a long term about the basic processes<strong>in</strong> each society which support human life and thosewhich are mov<strong>in</strong>g towards the destruction of humanlife. Both processes are known to be present <strong>in</strong> allsocieties. An equal balance of these processes favorsthe protection of human life as the desired hallmarkof a society which will be unavailable to engage <strong>in</strong> massmurder. Clearly, <strong>in</strong> some societies long before anymass murder has been executed, the balance <strong>in</strong> somesocieties is very much tipped towards destruction ofhuman life.The <strong>Genocide</strong> Early Warn<strong>in</strong>g System identifiesongo<strong>in</strong>g processes as differentiated from critical<strong>in</strong>cidents, which are also recorded; the first refers to,for <strong>in</strong>stance, the degree of protection of free speech,or the degree of discrim<strong>in</strong>ationof m<strong>in</strong>orities, while thesecond refers to dramatic events such as a major turn<strong>in</strong> policy as a result of the emergence of a new leader,the impact of go<strong>in</strong>g to war, or economic breakdown.Another level of analysis assembles <strong>in</strong>formationsabout societal processes as a whole such as previouslydescribed <strong>in</strong> the way of a free press, or the role of law,along with the roles of leadership or the major deci-sions and implementations by presidents, prime m<strong>in</strong>isters,dictators, church leaders, and heads of states orcultures.These levels of <strong>in</strong>formation are studied along atime cont<strong>in</strong>uum that beg<strong>in</strong>s with the ongo<strong>in</strong>g situation<strong>in</strong> a culture long before there may have developed whatwe call the genocidal fantasy or ideology. The monitor<strong>in</strong>gcont<strong>in</strong>ues by track<strong>in</strong>g when an idea of genocidebeg<strong>in</strong>s to be widely proposed and approved <strong>in</strong> a society,and ga<strong>in</strong>s political support of groups of people whoactually try to organize to implement the genocidalplan. Thus, when Hitler speaks of destroy<strong>in</strong>g the Jewslong before actual Holocaust events have come <strong>in</strong>toreality, these moments are tracked by the <strong>Genocide</strong>Early Warn<strong>in</strong>g System as dangerous moments thatalready go beyond underly<strong>in</strong>g historic patterns ofantisemitism <strong>in</strong> the society. When even <strong>in</strong> the greatAmerican democracy, an ethnic religious leader suchas Louis Farrakhan openly celebrates with his blackcommunity the burn<strong>in</strong>g of Jews <strong>in</strong> the ovens, this isa category of <strong>in</strong>formation that signals <strong>in</strong>creased danger<strong>in</strong> the <strong>Genocide</strong> Early Warn<strong>in</strong>g System. The earlywarn<strong>in</strong>g system is responsive to any ideas that referto keep<strong>in</strong>g other groups of people "<strong>in</strong> their" places,"kick<strong>in</strong>g out" an ethnic, national, or religious groupfrom the society, and certa<strong>in</strong>ly any ideas about elim<strong>in</strong>at<strong>in</strong>gthem <strong>in</strong> a "f<strong>in</strong>al solution. " Even <strong>in</strong> a society undersiege from its obvious enemies, such as Israel whichis surrounded by several Arab states that have a longhistory of <strong>in</strong>tention and have never given up the ideaof destroy<strong>in</strong>g the Jewish state, plans that are proposed<strong>in</strong> the Israeli society for gett<strong>in</strong>g rid of the Arabs <strong>in</strong> aforced migration or "transfer" will be registered <strong>in</strong> theearly warn<strong>in</strong>g system as a formulation of a genocidalfantasy or ideology that has to be watched carefully."The <strong>Genocide</strong> Early Warn<strong>in</strong>g System cont<strong>in</strong>uesby observ<strong>in</strong>g any events <strong>in</strong> a society which can becometriggers or precipitants for further escalations of thedestructive trends and genocidal fantasies present <strong>in</strong>that society. Often these <strong>in</strong>volve rumors of terroristevents that have been directed at one's people whichunderstandably fan the retaliatory <strong>in</strong>st<strong>in</strong>cts of thepopulation. This is the classic prescription of pogromsthroughout history; for example, rumors that Jewskilled a Christian sparked many pogroms or violentmassacre of Jews. What are natural feel<strong>in</strong>gs of revengeare taken as a basis for unleash<strong>in</strong>g the virulent genocidalmentality that has been await<strong>in</strong>g <strong>in</strong> the society — asultimately it awaits <strong>in</strong> all human societies at this po<strong>in</strong>t<strong>in</strong> our evolution as a species.F<strong>in</strong>ally, the <strong>Genocide</strong> Early Warn<strong>in</strong>g Systemtracks those situations and events where actual legalizationand <strong>in</strong>stitutionalization of genocide <strong>in</strong> a givensociety beg<strong>in</strong> to take place: the military give orders tokill the targeted group; the legal system justifies thosewho do the kill<strong>in</strong>g; the church system ignores or tra<strong>in</strong>sstudents to applaud the kill<strong>in</strong>g. In this manner thevarious <strong>in</strong>stitutions of society are coopted and corruptedas supporters of genocide.As the accompany<strong>in</strong>g typology shows, the <strong>Genocide</strong>Early Warn<strong>in</strong>g System has identified ten majorearly warn<strong>in</strong>g processes which are studied along theaxes described above.Early Warn<strong>in</strong>g, Intervention, and Prevention of <strong>Genocide</strong> 153
- Page 1 and 2:
GenocldeIn OurTlme- ,*"f* *An Annot
- Page 3:
DEDICATIONTo Raphael Lemkin(1901-19
- Page 6 and 7:
Chapter 5:The Armenian Genocide: Re
- Page 8 and 9:
Appendix 167Appendix: Chronology of
- Page 10 and 11:
ending sources of joy and hope. In
- Page 12 and 13:
Massive human suffering caused by p
- Page 14 and 15:
world without any reification and u
- Page 16 and 17:
CIIAPTER IETHNOCIDEby Alison Palmer
- Page 18 and 19:
als are tempted away by the promise
- Page 20 and 21:
Interactionsof Ethnocide and Genoci
- Page 22 and 23:
Chapter 1: AnnotatedBibliographyRea
- Page 24 and 25:
the inevitable extinction of tribal
- Page 26 and 27:
upon the purge of cultural and scie
- Page 28 and 29:
traditional ethnic and socio-cultur
- Page 30 and 31:
whites. Lizot proposes that integra
- Page 32 and 33:
¹ 1. 53 ¹Olson, James S. , and Ra
- Page 34 and 35:
tion of indigenes into state politi
- Page 36 and 37:
as a potential irredentist national
- Page 38 and 39:
serious questions about the notion
- Page 40 and 41:
ate and beleaguered institutions th
- Page 42 and 43:
In one of the most important works
- Page 44 and 45:
focusing on children, the most vuln
- Page 46 and 47:
~ 2. 35 ~Sereny, Gita. Into That Da
- Page 48 and 49:
were less than 200 Jewish survivors
- Page 50 and 51:
~ 2. 68 ~Nomberg-Przytyk, Sara. Aus
- Page 52 and 53:
of the war. The movement was known
- Page 54 and 55:
~ 2. 103 ~Wyman, David S. The Aband
- Page 56 and 57:
* 2. 122 ~Wiesenthal, Simon. The Su
- Page 58 and 59:
and Christianity. He argues that it
- Page 60 and 61:
Chapter 3THE ISSUE OF THE HOLOCAUST
- Page 62 and 63:
if we are to escape the mystificati
- Page 64 and 65:
outside the normal dimensions of ou
- Page 66 and 67:
historical event. All transformatio
- Page 68 and 69:
32. For an excellent understanding
- Page 70 and 71:
3 7Berenbaum, Michael. "The Uniquen
- Page 72 and 73:
Holocaust, a meaning with which we
- Page 74 and 75:
the Nazi exterminating drive, a pos
- Page 76 and 77:
framework, Marrus accepts the Holoc
- Page 78 and 79:
as "the cement of Jewish identity,
- Page 80 and 81:
'cry and you cry alone. ' So we kep
- Page 82 and 83:
of the body, combined with so many
- Page 84 and 85:
10. Lawrence Langer, Versions of Su
- Page 86 and 87:
~ 4. 10 ~Sichrovsky, Peter. Born Gu
- Page 88 and 89:
Appendix: The Diaryby Agi Rubinwith
- Page 90 and 91:
ella story. We could have eaten all
- Page 92 and 93:
which hardly anybody remains? Who k
- Page 94 and 95:
find a wise one who will solve it.
- Page 96 and 97:
Chapter 5THE ARMENIANGENOCIDE:REVIS
- Page 98 and 99:
The genocide was the culmination of
- Page 100 and 101:
Abdications and Retributions Turkey
- Page 102 and 103:
scene. They primarily targeted the
- Page 104 and 105:
Turkish and non-Turkish apologists
- Page 106 and 107:
and London: University Press of New
- Page 108 and 109:
supporters of Armenian independence
- Page 110 and 111:
that the history of the Armenians c
- Page 112 and 113: Realities Based on Ottoman Document
- Page 114 and 115: designed to falsely accuse Ottoman
- Page 116 and 117: and Western gullibility and predile
- Page 118 and 119: ambition to retain as much of Russi
- Page 120 and 121: Terror-FamineMemoir literature and
- Page 122 and 123: independence and viability of the U
- Page 124 and 125: So many members of the All-Ukraine
- Page 126 and 127: ~ 6. 26 ~Heller, Mikhail, and Aleks
- Page 128 and 129: ousness of the present one. In his
- Page 130 and 131: of structured social inequality, cr
- Page 132 and 133: or religious group, as such. "" The
- Page 134 and 135: and the general degradation of publ
- Page 136 and 137: easier by the fact that those who'd
- Page 138 and 139: 26. William Safire, "Object: Surviv
- Page 140 and 141: 74. Quoted in Paul Walker and Eric
- Page 142 and 143: es: People in the Machines of Death
- Page 144 and 145: ¹ 7. 16 ¹Dadrian, Vahakn N. "A Th
- Page 146 and 147: Corporate Enterprise at Auschwitz"
- Page 148 and 149: * 7. 47 +Nolan, Janne E. , and Albe
- Page 150 and 151: and sometimes irrational. " (p. 7)
- Page 152 and 153: able to evaluate various nuclear we
- Page 154 and 155: In an angry, stimulating book, Aske
- Page 156 and 157: Lang reflects on how technology fac
- Page 158 and 159: This is a pioneering collection of
- Page 160 and 161: "good reasons" for not offering the
- Page 164 and 165: sadisChart: Taking a Stand Against
- Page 166 and 167: This indicator refers to an advance
- Page 168 and 169: 14. Louis Rene Beres, "Genocide, St
- Page 170 and 171: to horrible new acts of violence ag
- Page 172 and 173: * 8. 27 ~Horowitz, Irving Louis. Ge
- Page 174 and 175: ~ 8. 41 ~Lifton, Robert J. , and Er
- Page 176 and 177: ~ 8. 56 ~Thompson, John L. P. "Geno
- Page 178 and 179: CountryDatesPer petratorsVictimsEst
- Page 180 and 181: Dwork, DeborahDyer, Gwynne. . . . .
- Page 182 and 183: Morgenthau, Henry . . . . . '. . .
- Page 184 and 185: TITLE INDEXThe Abandonment of the J
- Page 186 and 187: "Epilogue: The Nuclear Arms Raceand
- Page 188 and 189: The Industrialization of Soviet Rus
- Page 190 and 191: Psychiatric Aspects of the Preventi
- Page 192: When Memory ComesWhile Six Million