I527-290 ESRIF Final Report (WEB).indd - European Commission

AT
AT
AT
AT
+ Domestic security (research) culture
of coordination and pluralistic analysis
and associated practices can help
implement coordination on a
European scale
- Common practice of consocialism and
consensus democracy limit the potential
for developing shared European
understandings
+ Tradition and legal
provisions for “comprehensive
national defence”
Potential for a
comprehensive
approach at the
European level
- Security interpreted as a task on the
level of the state organization as a whole
FR
FR
- Tradition of
“comprehensive national
defence” tends to limit
threat perception and
preparedness to confront
threats to the national level;
European activities are
expected to have
immediate returns on
national security
+ Practice of involvement in
international mechanisms in fight
against organized crime, seen as an
opportunity to develop knowledge of
global trends in crime and advocate
own policies
FR
DE
FR
- Management of transversal issues
confined to the idea of national security;
comprehensive risk assessment and
strategic foresight increasingly vested in
the policing sector
- Idea of national security and
protection of own values
against challenges from within
(normative response to
totalitarian experience)
DE
DE
DE
NL
- Bundesländer-based competencies
in the civil protection sector
- Idea of a protective state
responsive to the specific
security requirements of its
citizens
- Security interpreted as a task on the
level of the state organization as a
whole/as a government matter
ES
NL
NL
SE
+ Practice of networking,
establishment of international security
networks and deems the national
approach to be aligned of that of
other nations and organizations
NL
ES
- Security interpreted as a task on the
level of the state organization as a whole,
including societal stakeholders
- Establishing international
linkages, but mainly in order to
support industry participation
in foreign (mainly U.S.) security
research programmes
SE
ES
ES
UK
+ Tendency to use EU institutions to
promote own agenda and to seek
support for own positions is limited by
mistrust against other security cultures
UK
- Typically uses EU institutions to
promote own agenda and to seek
support for own positions. But limited
by mistrust against other security
- Norm of reference is rather
the U.S. than the EU context
NO
307