Abstracts (PDF file, 1.8MB) - Society for Risk Analysis
Abstracts (PDF file, 1.8MB) - Society for Risk Analysis
Abstracts (PDF file, 1.8MB) - Society for Risk Analysis
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
SRA 2013 Annual Meeting <strong>Abstracts</strong><br />
W4-H.4 Poortvliet, P.M.*; Lokhorst, A.M.; Wageningen<br />
University; marijn.poortvliet@wur.nl<br />
<strong>Risk</strong>-related uncertainty and its relationship with<br />
citizens’ demand <strong>for</strong> regulation and institutional trust<br />
In this research, it is shown that psychological uncertainty<br />
about risks may play a moderating role on individuals’ demand<br />
<strong>for</strong> government regulation of risks and their trust in<br />
risk-managing government institutions. To test these ideas, first<br />
a survey (N = 1029) was conducted. Descriptions of specific<br />
risks from different risks domains (e.g., food hazards, medical<br />
risks) were presented to respondents and they were asked to<br />
react to questions about risk-specific uncertainty, risk<br />
perception, and demand <strong>for</strong> regulation by the government of<br />
the risk involved. Also, participants’ level of risk-specific<br />
knowledge was assessed. Results indicated that under the<br />
condition of uncertainty about risks a positive relationship<br />
emerged between the risk perceptions and demand <strong>for</strong><br />
government regulation of risks, whereas no such relationship<br />
showed when individuals do not experience uncertainty about<br />
the risk. Conversely, when people experience little risk-related<br />
uncertainty, having more knowledge about the risk topic<br />
involved lead to a weaker demand <strong>for</strong> government regulation of<br />
risks. For uncertain people, this relationship between<br />
knowledge and demand <strong>for</strong> regulation did not emerge.<br />
Secondly, in an experiment (N = 120) psychological uncertainty<br />
was manipulated to investigate effects on ability, benevolence<br />
and integrity types of trust. Results showed that people who<br />
received open vs. non-open government communication about a<br />
zoonosis reported higher levels of trust in the government<br />
agency in the uncertainty condition compared to the control<br />
condition. Altogether, the findings of the survey and the<br />
experiment suggest that successfully in<strong>for</strong>ming people about<br />
risks may preclude them from demanding government<br />
action—when they are not uncertain about the risk. Also, it is<br />
concluded that having strong risk perceptions only leads to a<br />
demand <strong>for</strong> government regulation and preclude them from<br />
lowering their levels of trust when individuals have feelings of<br />
uncertainty about those risks.<br />
M3-D.2 Powell, MR; U.S. Dept. of Agriculture;<br />
mpowell@oce.usda.gov<br />
<strong>Risk</strong>-Based Sampling: I Don’t Want to Weight In Vain<br />
Recently, there has been increased interest in developing<br />
scientific schemes <strong>for</strong> risk-based sampling of food, animals, and<br />
plants <strong>for</strong> effective en<strong>for</strong>cement of regulatory standards and<br />
efficient allocation of surveillance resources. The problem of<br />
risk-based sampling allocation presents a challenge similar to<br />
financial portfolio analysis. Markowitz (1952) laid the<br />
foundation <strong>for</strong> modern portfolio theory based on mean-variance<br />
optimization. However, a persistent challenge in implementing<br />
portfolio optimization is the problem of overfitting the model<br />
based on limited data, leading to false “optimal” portfolios and<br />
unstable asset weights (churn). In some cases, portfolio<br />
diversification based on simple heuristics (e.g., equal<br />
allocation) has better out-of-sample per<strong>for</strong>mance than complex<br />
portfolio optimization methods due to estimation uncertainty.<br />
Even <strong>for</strong> portfolios with a modest number of assets, the<br />
estimation window required <strong>for</strong> true optimization may imply an<br />
implausibly long stationary period. The implications <strong>for</strong><br />
risk-based sampling are illustrated by a simple simulation<br />
model of lot inspection <strong>for</strong> a small, heterogeneous group of<br />
producers. Under constrained optimization, the annual<br />
frequency of lot inspection <strong>for</strong> each producer is defined to be at<br />
least one and otherwise proportional to the product of known<br />
production volume and estimated prevalence of contaminated<br />
lots. Under a simpler decision rule, frequency is proportional to<br />
volume. Assuming stationarity, the “risk-based” sampling<br />
frequencies assigned to producers by constrained optimization<br />
remain highly unstable after 20 years. In the presence of<br />
infrequent transients (e.g., outbreaks or extreme contamination<br />
events), the relative per<strong>for</strong>mance of the decision rules<br />
converges in terms of the number of contaminated lots detected<br />
as the intensity of transients increases, and simply sampling<br />
proportional to volume is more likely to detect the occurrence<br />
of transients than the complex optimization decision rule.<br />
W4-D.1 Powers, CM*; Lehmann, G; Gift, J; Grieger, K; Money,<br />
M; Hendren , CO; Beaudrie, C; Davis , JM; U.S. EPA;<br />
powers.christina@epa.gov<br />
Comprehensive Environmental Assessment: Strategically<br />
linking Research, Assessment and <strong>Risk</strong> Management—<br />
Applied to Multiwalled Carbon Nanotubes<br />
The Comprehensive Environmental Assessment (CEA) approach<br />
is being developed by the U.S. Environmental Protection<br />
Agency (EPA) to identify and prioritize research gaps and risk<br />
related trade-offs in order to in<strong>for</strong>m decisions that will protect<br />
human health and the environment. The most recent<br />
application of the CEA approach to multiwalled carbon<br />
nanotubes (MWCNTs) successfully engaged expert<br />
stakeholders representing diverse technical (e.g., toxicology,<br />
material science, ecology) and sector (e.g., industry, academia,<br />
government) perspective. Stakeholders identified specific<br />
research priorities that could in<strong>for</strong>m future risk assessment and<br />
management ef<strong>for</strong>ts <strong>for</strong> these materials. Identified MWCNT<br />
research priorities generally related to 1) releases during the<br />
product life cycle; 2) environmental behavior in air, waste<br />
water and sediment; 3) exposure and dose in human<br />
occupational and consumer populations; and 4) impacts to<br />
human health and aquatic populations, as well as economic,<br />
societal and environmental resources. This presentation<br />
introduces these research priorities with a focus on initial work<br />
to describe how they might in<strong>for</strong>m future risk assessment and<br />
policy decisions <strong>for</strong> MWCNTs in a particular application,<br />
flame-retardant coatings applied to upholstery textiles. This<br />
introduction will help provide the foundation <strong>for</strong> a panel<br />
discussion focused on approaches to and benefits of creating<br />
better linkages along the in<strong>for</strong>mation chain from research to<br />
policy. Participation in this discussion will in<strong>for</strong>m researchers,<br />
risk assessors, and risk managers about (1) specific research<br />
initiatives that could in<strong>for</strong>m future assessments and policy<br />
ef<strong>for</strong>ts <strong>for</strong> MWCNTs, and (2) the potential utility of applying<br />
CEA to <strong>for</strong>tify linkages between research planning, risk<br />
assessment and risk management <strong>for</strong> other emerging<br />
chemicals, materials or technologies. The views expressed in<br />
this abstract are those of the author and do not necessarily<br />
represent the views or policies of the U.S. EPA.<br />
M4-D.3 Pradhan, AK; University of Maryland, College Park;<br />
akp@umd.edu<br />
Application of quantitative microbial risk assessments to<br />
address critical and emerging food safety issues<br />
Many foodborne pathogens including the zoonotic ones<br />
continue to cause significant disease burden worldwide. These<br />
pathogens cause considerable public health impact and are a<br />
major concern to food industries and regulatory agencies. In a<br />
recent report by the Centers <strong>for</strong> Disease Control and<br />
Prevention (CDC), it has been estimated that three pathogens,<br />
Salmonella spp., Listeria monocytogenes, and parasite<br />
Toxoplasma gondii, together account <strong>for</strong> more than 70% of all<br />
estimated deaths in the U.S. per year attributed to foodborne<br />
pathogens. Salmonella spp. and Toxoplasma gondii with 28%<br />
and 24% of total deaths were ranked the first and second in<br />
terms of estimated annual deaths. Given the current emphasis<br />
on risk-based approaches to evaluate food safety issues, both in<br />
industry and regulatory agencies, and to develop risk-in<strong>for</strong>med<br />
polices and strategies, it is critical to provide science-based<br />
in<strong>for</strong>mation that will aid in better understanding and managing<br />
food safety risks arising from different pathogens. Recent<br />
advances in microbial risk assessments provide tools <strong>for</strong><br />
modeling food systems in a systematic and objective way <strong>for</strong><br />
making better in<strong>for</strong>med food safety decisions and <strong>for</strong> evaluating<br />
potential intervention strategies. In this presentation, the<br />
importance of in<strong>for</strong>mation and data collection, and applications<br />
of quantitative microbial risk assessments to address critical<br />
food safety issues will be discussed with respect to case studies<br />
such as Salmonella in dry pet foods and Toxoplasma gondii in<br />
organic or free range meats. The recent outbreaks of<br />
salmonellosis associated with dry pet foods and treats have<br />
considerably emphasized the role of dry pet foods as a vehicle<br />
of pathogen exposure <strong>for</strong> both pets and their owners. In the<br />
CDC report, it has been estimated that 50% of all human<br />
exposures to Toxoplasma gondii are foodborne, thus making<br />
this parasite a serious food safety concern.<br />
December 8-11, 2013 - Baltimore, MD