Abstracts (PDF file, 1.8MB) - Society for Risk Analysis
Abstracts (PDF file, 1.8MB) - Society for Risk Analysis
Abstracts (PDF file, 1.8MB) - Society for Risk Analysis
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
SRA 2013 Annual Meeting <strong>Abstracts</strong><br />
M2-J.2 Colyvan, M; University of Sydney;<br />
mark.colyvan@sydney.edu.au<br />
Value of In<strong>for</strong>mation Models and Data Collection in<br />
Conservation Biology<br />
I will look at recent uses of value of in<strong>for</strong>mation studies in<br />
conservation biology. In the past, it has been mostly assumed<br />
that more and better quality data will lead to better<br />
conservation management decisions. Indeed, this assumption<br />
lies behind and motivates a great deal of work in conservation<br />
biology. Of course, more data can lead to better decisions in<br />
some cases but decision-theoretic models of the value of<br />
in<strong>for</strong>mation show that in many cases the cost of the data is too<br />
high and thus not worth the ef<strong>for</strong>t of collecting. While such<br />
value of in<strong>for</strong>mation studies are well known in economics and<br />
decision theory circles, their applications in conservation<br />
biology are relatively new and rather controversial. I will<br />
discuss some reasons to be wary of, at least, wholesale<br />
acceptance of such studies. Apart from anything else, value of<br />
in<strong>for</strong>mation models treat conservation biology as a servant to<br />
conservation management, where all that matters is the<br />
relevant conservation management decision. In short,<br />
conservation biology loses some of its scientific independence<br />
and the fuzzy boundary between science and policy becomes<br />
even less clear.<br />
M2-I.4 Connelly, EB*; Lambert, JH; Thekdi, SA; University of<br />
Virginia, University of Virginia, University of Richmond;<br />
ec5vc@virginia.edu<br />
Robust supply chain investments <strong>for</strong> disaster<br />
preparedness and community resilience: An application<br />
to Rio de Janeiro, Brazil<br />
Effective disaster preparedness and response requires<br />
investment in resilient and agile emergency management<br />
systems. Meanwhile there are scarce resources <strong>for</strong> emergency<br />
supply chains and related operations. Resource allocations to<br />
these systems must consider multiple criteria and deep<br />
uncertainties related to population behaviors, climate change,<br />
innovative technologies, wear and tear, extreme events, and<br />
others. The methods demonstrated in this paper help to<br />
prioritize among emergency supply chain investments by<br />
employing an integration of scenario analysis and multi-criteria<br />
decision analysis. The results will aid emergency management<br />
agencies in maintaining and increasing per<strong>for</strong>mance of<br />
emergency supply chains and logistics systems. The methods<br />
will be applied to disaster reduction initiatives of firstresponder<br />
agencies in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, whose overall<br />
society and favela populations are vulnerable to landslides,<br />
blackouts, radiological events, etc., and will host in the next few<br />
years the World Cup and the Olympics.<br />
W2-F.1 Conrad, JW, Jr*; Paulson, G; Reiss, R; Patterson, J;<br />
Conrad Law & Policy Counsel; jamie@conradcounsel.com<br />
Legal context <strong>for</strong> US federal agency peer reviews<br />
Any discussion of federal agency peer reviews must begin with<br />
the legal framework that constrains them (and any desired<br />
re<strong>for</strong>ms). For agency-administered peer reviews, the principal<br />
legal authorities are the Federal Advisory Committee Act, the<br />
Ethics in Government Act and even the federal criminal code.<br />
For peer reviews administered by agency contractors, federal<br />
acquisition regulations largely govern. This dichotomy is<br />
increasingly being recognized as problematic by concerned<br />
stakeholders. Executive Branch and agency policies are also<br />
highly important, particularly OMB’s Peer Review Bulletin. This<br />
presentation will lay out the relevant legal framework and then<br />
explore current controversies and proposed solutions.<br />
W3-C.4 Convertino, MC*; Liang, SL; University of Minnesota;<br />
matteoc@umn.edu<br />
Unveiling the Spatio-Temporal Cholera Outbreak in<br />
Cameroon: a Model <strong>for</strong> Public Health Engineering<br />
Cholera is one of the deadliest and widespread diseases<br />
worldwide in developing and undeveloped countries. Education,<br />
water sanitation, and human mobility are together the major<br />
factors affecting the disease spreading and these factors can be<br />
enhanced by unregulated land development and climate<br />
change. Here we investigate the cholera outbreak in the Far<br />
North region of Cameroon in 2010 that has seen 2046 cases of<br />
infection with 241 cases and a fatality rate of 12% (600 deaths)<br />
at the peak of infection. In this study, we further develop a<br />
metacommunity model predicting the spatio-temporal evolution<br />
of the cholera outbreak by incorporating long-term water<br />
resource availability and rainfall event dependent resources.<br />
Susceptible, infected, and recovered individuals are modeled in<br />
the region as a function of their mobility and pathogen spread.<br />
We apply a novel radiation model of human mobility to better<br />
characterize the secondary pathway of transmission. The model<br />
is capable to predict the spatiotemporal evolution and<br />
prevalence of the 2010 cholera epidemic with an average<br />
accuracy of 88 % with respect to the epidemiological data. We<br />
find that cholera is a highly heterogeneous and asynchronous<br />
process in which multiple drivers have different relative<br />
importance in space. Using global sensitivity and uncertainty<br />
analysis, we find hydrogeomorphological and social controls on<br />
the distribution and emergence of outbreaks in different health<br />
districts. Particularly, human mobility and the available water<br />
resources are predominantly important in urbanized mountain<br />
and floodplain regions, respectively. The model predicts cases<br />
at a scale that is two orders of magnitude finer than the health<br />
district scale, which allows one a precise healthcare planning<br />
and response after the onset. The model is designed as a<br />
parsimonious model to be readily applicable to any country and<br />
scale of analysis facing cholera outbreaks. Moreover, because<br />
of the generality of its structure the model can be easily tuned<br />
to different pathogen ecology types <strong>for</strong> waterborne diseases.<br />
December 8-11, 2013 - Baltimore, MD