2454 final report.pdf - Agra CEAS Consulting

Table 3-20 Estimated potential benefit of current CPHR measures and/or national control measures
HO Key host
plant(s)
Diabrotica virgifera maize
virgifera
Clavibacter
michiganensis ssp.
sepedonicus (potato ring
rot)
Ralstonia solanacearum
(brown rot)
Globodera rostochiensis
and Pallida (Potato cyst
nematode)
Potato Spindle Tuber
Viroid (PSTVd)
Colorado beetle
(Leptinotarsa
decemlineata)
potatoes
potatoes
potatoes
potatoes
Bemisia Tabaci tomatoes, other
horticulture
Estimated benefit
Evaluation of the Community Plant Health Regime: Final Report
DG SANCO Evaluation Framework Contract Lot 3 (Food Chain)
Source: cost survey
6 MS (BE, DE, ES, FR, PL, SI) have indicated that the measures taken under the current CPHR are considered
to have been of economic benefit, ultimately protecting a total susceptible area of 4.5 million ha.
Source: cost survey
14 MS (BE, CZ, DE, DK, EE, ES, FI, FR, HU, IE, LT, NL, SE, SK) have indicated that the measures taken
under the current CPHR are considered to have been of economic benefit, ultimately protecting a total
susceptible area of 760,000 ha (11//14MS). This relates to a total production volume (potatoes) of some 6.8
million tonnes in France and 6.2 million tonnes in NL.
MS: England (Source: ADAS (2000):
Estimated benefit: Net Social Benefit: £88.2 mln
Benefit : Cost ratio of current policy (£222,000 per year): 29.8:1 over 30 years period
Source: cost survey
14 MS (BE, CZ, DE, DK, EE, ES, FR, HU, IE, IT, NL, SE, SI, SK) have indicated that the measures taken under
the current CPHR are considered to have been of economic benefit, ultimately protecting a total susceptible area
of 840,000 ha (11//14MS). This relates to a total production volume (potatoes) of some 6.8 million tonnes in
France and 6.2 million tonnes in NL.
Source: cost survey
5 MS (CZ, HU, PL, SE, SI) have indicated that the measures taken under the current CPHR are considered to
have been of economic (and environmental) benefit, ultimately leading to the protection of a total susceptible
area (potatoes) of 536,000 ha (4/5 MS, of which 500,000 ha in PL).
Source: cost survey
3 MS (FR, NL, SI) have indicated that the measures taken under the current CPHR are considered to have been
of economic benefit; in the NL this has ultimately led to the protection of a total susceptible area (potatoes) of
147,000 ha and a production volume (potatoes) of some 6.2 million tonnes.
potatoes MS: England (Source: ADAS (2000))
Estimated benefit: Net Social Benefit: £3.35 million
Benefit : Cost ratio of current policy (£38,000 per year): 7.5:1 over 30 years period.
Source: cost survey
2 MS (FI, IE) have indicated that the measures taken under the current CPHR are considered to have been of
economic benefit, in the case of FI ultimately leading to the protection of a total susceptible area (potatoes) of
25,000 ha or a total production volume of 750,000 tonnes.
MS: England (Source: ADAS (2000))
Estimated benefit: Net Social Benefit: £11.1 million.
Benefit : Cost ratio of current policy (£254,000 per year): 3.1:1 over 15 years period
FCEC 207