2454 final report.pdf - Agra CEAS Consulting

Evaluation of the Community Plant Health Regime: Final Report
DG SANCO Evaluation Framework Contract Lot 3 (Food Chain)
Table 3-38: Evaluation of CPHR performance during 1993-2008 – utility and
effectiveness of policy measures
Utility (b) Effectiveness (b)
Policy measure (a):
Surveillance (intra-EU)
Compulsory surveillance (emergency and control measures; PZs) +++ ++
Other (non-compulsory) surveillance +++ +
Reporting and notification of findings +++ +
Import regime
Import inspections +++ ++
Notification of interceptions (EUROPHYT) +++ ++
Dealing with non-compliance +++ +
Cooperation with customs +++ +
Derogations (small quantities, local markets, private consumption) +/+++ (c) +
Additional declaration and special arrangements (Annex VI) + +
Checks at final destination +++ +
Emergency measures + +
Intra-EU movement
Plant passport system in general ++ +
Plant passport document + +
Producer registration +++ +++
Inspection of registered producers +++ +
Issuing of plant passports by registered nurseries +++ +
Exemptions +++ ++
Protected Zones (regionalisation)
PZ system in general ++ +
PZ plant passports + +
Control and emergency measures (outbreaks and new findings)
Control measures +/+++ (c) +/+++ (c)
Emergency measures + +
Emergency preparedness +++ +
Activities in support of the CPHR
Research and development +++ +
Diagnostic laboratories and training +++ +
CPHR financial framework
Solidarity funding +++ +
(a) Includes the CPHR instruments and tools currently foreseen for the implementation of each policy area;
excludes issues for which instruments/tools are not currently provided.
(b) Utility: extent to which the impact of the measures corresponds to the identified needs;
Effectiveness: extent to which the measure has reached the objectives for which it was set
The extent to which each policy measure has been useful and effective was assessed against the specific
objectives of each measure, as outlined in Table 2-2.
The utility and effectiveness are rated on a scale of: + (low), ++ (moderate), +++ (high).
(c) Depends on specific measure.
Source: FCEC, based on results of the evaluation
Food Chain Evaluation Consortium 290