ARBEITSBERICHT - Johann Heinrich von Thünen-Institut - Bund.de

Review protocol for life cycle assessments according to ISO 14044 9g) Critical review, where applicable:Compliance with the methodologicalrequirements of ISO 14044 (according toClause 4)Compliance with thedocumentationrequirements of ISO14044 (according toClause 5)1) name and affiliation of reviewers; - √2) critical review reports; - Vorgesehen3) responses to recommendations. - √III. FOR LCA STUDIES SUPPORTING COMPARATIVE ASSERTIONS INTENDED TO BE DISCLOSED TO THE PUBLIC (Clause 5.3)For LCA studies supporting comparative assertions intended to be disclosed to the public, the following issues shall be addressed (Clause 5.3.1):a) analysis of material and energy flows to justify their inclusion or exclusion; √ √b) assessment of the precision, completeness and representativeness of data used; √ √c) description of the equivalence of the systems being compared in accordance with 4.2.3.7;Nicht anwendbar, da kein direkter Vergleich inStudie vorgesehen; √ -d) description of the critical review process; - √e) an evaluation of the completeness of the LCIA; - √e') result of the final sensitivity analysis of the inputs and outputs data , including mass, energy and environmentalsignificance criteria, so that la inputs that cumulatively contribute more than a defined amount to the total areincluded in the study Aufgrund von Vorstudien hinfällig; √ √f) a statement as to whether or not international acceptance exists for the selected category indicators and ajustification for their use; Hinfällig, da Bezug auf EN 15804; √ √g) an explanation for the scientific and technical validity and environmental relevance of the category indicatorsused in the study; Hinfällig, da Bezug auf EN 15804; √ -h) the results of the uncertainty and sensitivity analyses; Hinfällig, da Bezug auf EN 15804; √ -i) evaluation of the significance of the differences found. Hinfällig, da Bezug auf EN 15804; √ -If grouping is included in the LCA, add the following (Clause 5.3.2):a) the procedures and results used for grouping; - -b) a statement that conclusions and recommendations derived from grouping are based on value-choices; - -c) a justification of the criteria used for normalization and grouping (these can be personal, organizational ornational value-choices); - -Dr. F. Werner, Environment & Development, Zurich