Mentoring Future Leaders
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
<strong>Mentoring</strong> <strong>Future</strong> <strong>Leaders</strong><br />
Helpful Hints for Giving Feedback<br />
© Learning Link International<strong> </strong><br />
April 2005<br />
(Landsberg, 1996, p.25)<br />
Exercise: Pairs<br />
1. Look at your learning partner and give a “camera shot” description of<br />
what you see. Then tell the person what you think (based on what you<br />
saw) as well as how you feel (as a result of your thoughts).<br />
• I see<br />
• I think<br />
• I feel<br />
Destructive<br />
Feedback<br />
Creates defensiveness;<br />
focuses on blame<br />
Constructive<br />
Feedback<br />
Creates trust and cooperation;<br />
focuses on<br />
improvements –<br />
possible or achieved<br />
How to Give<br />
Quality Feedback<br />
• Contract to discuss issues<br />
• Acknowledge mentee’s feelings<br />
Does not improve skill Increases skill • Focus on ‘skills’ not ’person’<br />
• Be specific about desired<br />
behaviour<br />
• Suggest practical steps<br />
Undermines confidence<br />
and self-esteem<br />
Leaves person in the<br />
dark<br />
Leaves person feeling<br />
being ‘judged’<br />
Improves confidence in<br />
ability and potential<br />
Clarifies ‘exactly where I<br />
stand’ and ‘what to do<br />
next’<br />
Leaves person feeling<br />
‘helped’<br />
• Position as need to ‘build’ or<br />
‘demonstrate’ vs. ‘don’t have’ or<br />
‘must prove’<br />
• Balance negatives and positives;<br />
provide constructive actions<br />
• Verify with questions; ask mentee<br />
to recap<br />
• Jointly arrive at plan<br />
• Invite mentee to assess own<br />
performance first<br />
• Offer support for future<br />
2. Refer to the feedback guidelines on the next page and plan feedback<br />
you want to give to someone else in the room. Give feedback to the<br />
person according to the guidelines.<br />
Module 4 - <strong>Mentoring</strong> Skills Page ! 1