25.10.2012 Views

Laurie Bauer - WordPress.com — Get a Free Blog Here

Laurie Bauer - WordPress.com — Get a Free Blog Here

Laurie Bauer - WordPress.com — Get a Free Blog Here

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

THE LINGUISTICS STUDENT’S HANDBOOK 20<br />

amat ‘he or she or it loves’<br />

amāmus ‘we love’<br />

amātis ‘you (plural) love’<br />

amant ‘they love’<br />

The amount of space given over to other matters was <strong>com</strong>paratively constrained.<br />

This experience gave rise to the idea that grammar was a matter of<br />

such paradigms. Thus the idea arose that Latin had a lot of grammar, while<br />

English hardly had any (because there is very little to put in equivalent paradigms,<br />

as people discovered when they started trying to write English grammars<br />

on the model of the Latin ones they knew). So we have a meaning of<br />

grammar, perhaps now no longer encountered, according to which grammar<br />

dealt with the shapes of the words (i.e. what we would now call morphology,<br />

specifically inflectional morphology) and the uses to which those words could<br />

be put (typically in sections with titles like ‘The uses of the ablative’ or ‘The<br />

uses of the subjunctive’). This latter part, relatively undeveloped in most<br />

grammar books from before the twentieth century, deals with putting words<br />

together to make sentences, i.e. with syntax. So grammar meant (and still<br />

means for some) ‘morphology and syntax’, specifically here excluding anything<br />

to do with the sound structure of language or the vocabulary of the<br />

language.<br />

Traditional grammar<br />

This picture of what grammar is and what grammar does, deriving from<br />

the classical Greek and Latin traditions, was handed down in Western<br />

society for generations, and remained virtually intact for language-teaching<br />

purposes well into the twentieth century. Each word is assigned to a part of<br />

speech (noun, verb, adjective, adverb, etc.), of which there are often said<br />

to be eight. These are assumed as given categories (see the section 5).<br />

School students traditionally showed their mastery of the system by considering<br />

each word in a text in turn, and explaining what cell in the<br />

paradigm it came from. This is called parsing, and involves looking at a<br />

word like amāmus and saying that it is the first person plural of the present<br />

tense indicative of the verb amo ‘I love’, for example. Students were also<br />

expected to write on the basis of the classical models provided. We can call<br />

this picture of what grammar is and does ‘traditional grammar’. The extent<br />

to which such methods encouraged good writing, which was clearly the<br />

aim, is perhaps best left unexplored, although it should be recalled that<br />

until the nineteenth century, most of the people being taught to read and<br />

write were those who had the leisure and frequently the desire to learn the<br />

skills well.

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!