27.12.2013 Views

Philip Arthur Bence PhD Thesis - Research@StAndrews:FullText

Philip Arthur Bence PhD Thesis - Research@StAndrews:FullText

Philip Arthur Bence PhD Thesis - Research@StAndrews:FullText

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

365<br />

Stewart 5<br />

Rahner 3<br />

Barth 2<br />

Bultmann 1<br />

Fosdick 0.5<br />

Other 2<br />

520ne college indicated equal pluralities for the<br />

Episcopal and Congregational denominations; that college's<br />

responses are counted half for each of those churches.<br />

group together a large number of conservative<br />

colleges which either are free from any denominational tie<br />

or are associated with a small, relatively new denomination<br />

(sponsoring only one British college). Within this<br />

section's analysis, I group these as though they comprised<br />

one denomination, the 'Evangelicals'.<br />

In relation to each data line, I noted the<br />

denominations whose composite survey responses placed them<br />

on extremes. Next, I considered the relative position of<br />

the intermediate figures, noting whether they appear closest<br />

to one of the extremes, or to the midpoint between them.<br />

When I had done this for all the data lines, I looked for,<br />

in relation to each denomination, traits in the teaching of<br />

preaching where the data revealed significant patterns<br />

(themes where a denomination's lecturers' responses<br />

consistently placed them in similar positions relative to<br />

the other denominational groups, e.g., on the upper extreme.<br />

This would indicate at least the possibility of a<br />

denominational influence.)<br />

85% of the Evangelical lecturers come from the<br />

Lloyd—Jones lecturer group. While it is true that half of<br />

the Baptist lecturers come from that same theologically<br />

conservative ilk, the Baptist group freely leaves the<br />

conservative camp at other points to be presented below.<br />

Thus, the data indicates a small but significant<br />

denominational influence here; Baptist lecturers (and<br />

preachers as taught by those lecturers) give greater<br />

attention to the Bible than their Evangelical counterparts.<br />

A similar effect is noted in the previous section.<br />

'Related' college lecturers apparently give more attention<br />

to Scripture than independent college lecturers. There<br />

could be some correlation between these two Bible related<br />

patterns. All of the Evangelical colleges are also<br />

'independent'. Three of seven Baptist colleges fall into<br />

the 'related' category. The remainder are independent.<br />

.--"'The two Baptist composite responses to question<br />

ten contradict the pattern set in other Baptist responses<br />

listed on table 79.<br />

7The following table compares actual, and<br />

theologically predicted, means.<br />

Actual Predicted<br />

Baptist 3.0 3.3<br />

Episcopal 3.7 3.7<br />

Presbyterian 2.8 3.1<br />

Evangelical 3.8 3.4<br />

Of the six choices that question eight offered, only

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!