12.07.2015 Views

Biofuel co-products as livestock feed - Opportunities and challenges

Biofuel co-products as livestock feed - Opportunities and challenges

Biofuel co-products as livestock feed - Opportunities and challenges

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS
  • No tags were found...

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

512<strong>Biofuel</strong> <strong>co</strong>-<strong>products</strong> <strong>as</strong> <strong>livestock</strong> <strong>feed</strong> – <strong>Opportunities</strong> <strong>and</strong> <strong>challenges</strong><strong>and</strong> Kamra, 22). The bitter t<strong>as</strong>te <strong>and</strong> variable <strong>co</strong>mpositionof neem seed cake <strong>and</strong> neem seed kernel cake, due to depulping,de-<strong>co</strong>rticating <strong>and</strong> oil extracting, affect its value <strong>as</strong>a <strong>feed</strong>. In addition, crude fibre <strong>and</strong> CP are both affected bythe methods employed <strong>and</strong> degree of processing (Dutta,P<strong>and</strong>a <strong>and</strong> Kamra, 22).Abbeddou <strong>and</strong> Makkar (19) summarized the potentialfor detoxification of seed cakes from non-<strong>co</strong>nventionalsources that <strong>co</strong>uld <strong>co</strong>ntribute protein for <strong>livestock</strong>.Azadirachta indica, the source of neem cake, after w<strong>as</strong>hingcan be used at up to 45 percent of the <strong>co</strong>ncentrate incalf diets, while other treatments for this product includemethanol, urea <strong>and</strong> alkali extraction. Ricinus <strong>co</strong>mmunismeal <strong>co</strong>oked at 100 °C for 50 minutes <strong>co</strong>uld be added<strong>as</strong> 15 percent of chick diets, <strong>and</strong>, with the addition of4 percent lime, included at 10 to 15 percent of the diet forsheep <strong>and</strong> beef cattle. HCN levels in Hevea br<strong>as</strong>iliensis meal<strong>co</strong>uld be reduced by soaking in water to allow fermentation,but <strong>livestock</strong> trials have not <strong>as</strong> yet been <strong>co</strong>nducted.Crambe abyssinica meal de-hulled <strong>and</strong> subjected to a heatcarbonatetreatment is acceptable to beef cattle, <strong>and</strong> canreplace up to two-thirds of the soybean meal in the diet.Pongamia pinnata meal after w<strong>as</strong>hing with water or alkalitreatment can be included at up to 13.5 percent of the <strong>co</strong>ncentratesin lamb diets. Br<strong>as</strong>sica juncea h<strong>as</strong> been selected <strong>as</strong>a break crop for cereal l<strong>and</strong>s, particularly in hot are<strong>as</strong> <strong>and</strong>an extracted oilseed cake is available (Braid, 25).The benefits of lipid <strong>co</strong>-<strong>products</strong> are summarized byWiesman, Segman <strong>and</strong> Yarmolinsky (18), although many arealso available from the production of ethanol. The advantagesinclude acting <strong>as</strong> a source of vitamin E, required for manyessential functions in both humans <strong>and</strong> <strong>livestock</strong> includinggrowth <strong>and</strong> reproduction; <strong>as</strong> a source of carotenes,normally available to the grazing animal but lost whenforage is <strong>co</strong>nserved <strong>as</strong> hay or silage; <strong>and</strong> providing phytosterols,important in reducing the absorption of cholesterol,thereby helping to reduce cardiov<strong>as</strong>cular dise<strong>as</strong>e (squaleneh<strong>as</strong> similar properties in this respect). They also have antiinflammatory,anti-bacterial, anti-ulcerative <strong>and</strong> anti-tumourproperties, <strong>and</strong> are beneficial to the immune system ofpiglets. Polyethenols are able to improve the efficiency ofprotein use in ruminants, reduce urea <strong>co</strong>ntent of manure,inhibit bloat, <strong>and</strong> help <strong>co</strong>mbat sub-clinical helminth infections.Lecithins act <strong>as</strong> dust suppressors (dustiness h<strong>as</strong> beenidentified <strong>as</strong> a <strong>co</strong>nstraint to intake by ruminants), emulsifiers<strong>and</strong> <strong>as</strong> a source of essential fatty acids (Wiesman, Segman<strong>and</strong> Yarmolinsky, 18). The authors stress the need for thoroughtesting of these <strong>products</strong> obtained from biodieselproduction to avoid toxic <strong>co</strong>mpounds reaching humans <strong>and</strong><strong>livestock</strong>. Shurson et al. (10) stress the problems likely to been<strong>co</strong>untered from an excess of methanol in the diet <strong>and</strong>in particular the need to <strong>co</strong>ntrol intake of glycerine in pigsbecause of the slow rate of excretion of methanol.Nutritive value of biodiesel <strong>co</strong>-<strong>products</strong>RuminantsThe two major <strong>co</strong>-<strong>products</strong> from the biodiesel process areprotein-rich cakes or meals, <strong>and</strong> glycerol. The cakes <strong>and</strong>meals have long been major sources of CP in <strong>co</strong>mmercial<strong>livestock</strong> <strong>and</strong> poultry production, the market being dominatedby soybean meal (Makkar, Kumar <strong>and</strong> Becker, 21).Glycerol, a glu<strong>co</strong>se precursor, h<strong>as</strong> traditionally been used<strong>as</strong> a drench for dairy <strong>co</strong>ws to <strong>co</strong>mbat ketosis, often shortlyafter calving, because it is rapidly fermentable within therumen <strong>and</strong> favours a decre<strong>as</strong>e in the acetate-to-propionateratio (Kalscheur et al., 7). Incre<strong>as</strong>ing propionate benefitsthe supply of glu<strong>co</strong>neogenic substrate reaching the liver,<strong>and</strong> incre<strong>as</strong>ing butyrate en<strong>co</strong>urages ruminal epithelial tissuegrowth, possibly leading to improved absorption ofnutrients (Kalscheur et al., 7). However, it can also be used<strong>as</strong> a supplement for transition <strong>co</strong>ws, or <strong>as</strong> a replacementfor maize at 10–12 percent of the diet, but its effect incausing a reduction in fibre digestibility is similar to that ofstarch (Kalscheur et al., 7). The authors re<strong>co</strong>mmend analysisof individual batches of <strong>feed</strong> rather than depending onbook values when formulating diets, <strong>and</strong> warn that someagricultural crops may not be ideal <strong>co</strong>-<strong>co</strong>mponents in dietsb<strong>as</strong>ed on DG. For example, a <strong>co</strong>mbination of DDGS plusalfalfa hay results in a <strong>feed</strong> <strong>co</strong>ntaining too much CP. Addingglycerine to the diet will favour a propionate-butyrate,rather than acetic, rumen fermentation, although this maybe affected by the level of glycerine <strong>and</strong> the <strong>co</strong>mposition ofthe rumen flora (Drouillard, 8). Young cattle fed glycerineearly in life <strong>and</strong> then fed a diet <strong>co</strong>ntaining maize gluten<strong>feed</strong>, which had a glycerol <strong>co</strong>ntent of 4.9 percent in thefinishing period, have performed better than cattle fed thesame finishing diet but without the addition of glycerineat the earlier stage, suggesting that rumen adaptationto glycerine may have a relatively long carry-over period(Drouillard, 8).In Europe, rapeseed <strong>co</strong>-<strong>products</strong> are widely used incattle, pig <strong>and</strong> poultry diets (Hippenstiel et al., 11).Re<strong>co</strong>mmendations from Germany are available for dailyamounts of both rapeseed meal (solvent extracted) <strong>and</strong>rapeseed cake (mechanically extracted), which range from4 kg of rapeseed meal for a dairy <strong>co</strong>w (2 kg of rapeseedcake) to 0–100 g of the meal <strong>and</strong> 50–100 g of the cakefor laying hens (Hippenstiel et al., 11, especially Table 16).A safety quality <strong>as</strong>sessment of rapeseed cake for cattle isrequired because variations in processing can affect thechemical <strong>co</strong>mposition, particularly that of crude fat <strong>and</strong>CP, making ration formulation using this product difficult.Rapeseed meal can <strong>co</strong>mpletely replace soybean meal indairy <strong>co</strong>w rations, although there may be differences inintake of energy, rumen degradability <strong>and</strong> amino acidprofiles between the two sources (Hippenstiel et al., 11).Hippenstiel et al. (11) also <strong>co</strong>mments on the use of glycer-

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!